23456th poster gets a cookie (cookie thread (Part 7)) (Part 11)

General
#18485

i know you can hear me, may.

#18486
Which should I get?
  • Chocolate chip cookie (warm)
  • Ice cream milkshake (cookies and cream)

0 voters

#18487

insatiable greed voice: both

3 Likes
#18488

Proooobably getting killed sorry

4 Likes
#18489

why. why. WHY!!

2 Likes
#18490

trying to get a gift for someone i barely know and am not really close with and its super annoying

3 Likes
#18491

Cash, or a VISA gift card.

#18492

We do it every year!

2 Likes
#18493

Bad advice above

4 Likes
#18494

he’s rich

2 Likes
#18495

traditional doesn’t beget reason

2 Likes
#18496

The issue isn’t even direct slippage, it’s the angleshooting that comes from basically every potential poster being somehow involved in the game

5 Likes
#18497

so you think every single interaction a person has is based off their alignment in a mafia game? aren’t you just projecting?

4 Likes
#18498

Technically, having the cookie thread at all (a publicly available place on the same site as this where people casually discuss their lives, allowing people to angleshoot) is a minor integrity issue for normal games, but nobody gives a shit because the tradeoff of closing it is not at all worth it then. The calculus changes when Everybody is in One Game

4 Likes
#18499

i considered getting him dried fruit but i dunno if he even likes fruit

1 Like
#18500

i have no idea who this guy is

1 Like
#18501


all things considered, it’s still a darn great game. Just finished (watching someone play) the 3rd Chapter, and it brought tears to my eyes.

((2nd Chapter still hurt me the most. 1st Chapter hurt me the least.))

1 Like
#18502

my assistant and i have reached a conclusion:

khm.

“it is hopeless”

3 Likes
#18503

also i have a headache again

2 Likes
#18504

Rubs your head

2 Likes