6767th poster gets a cookie (cookie thread (Part 7)) (Part 11)

idt its totally my thing but also im still gonna support it bc more indie animation is always good
glitch my bleoved

3 Likes

you think they’re not gonna greenlight the brainchild of rubberross and egoraptor, with jschlatt in the VA booth?

2 Likes

(I’m excluding Knights of Guinevere because I think that the only world where that show doesn’t get greenlit is if something has gone very wrong with the merch sales.)

i also don’t think it’s a very good trailer at telling me what’s interesting about the characters like one of them (with neat character design & seems generally heroic) cares about another one (who is funny) and the third one is traumatized. instead they spend the time. Instead it spends the time asking if you remember old videogames (I don’t)

2 Likes

ash how could you forget the twitter drama

1 Like

hey the discourse could spiral even further out of control

1 Like

My understanding of Twitter drama is through a Bluesky post about a Tumblr post about an Instagram Reel about a Twitter post.

1 Like

i feel like this would be a great like, childrens cartoon but for nerds instead of people who like mickey mouse but itll probably be too edgy for that
like idk the trailer’s format and the jokes in it highkey reminded me of the mario movie more than anything
it feels like a kids movie :joy_wolf:

2 Likes

wait was there drama with Guinevere
was the show too good or something

my recollection of tumblr posts i saw about it is that dana terrace went on twitter & said some character (green?) was not transgender

1 Like

oh yeah
basically everyone headcanoned frankie as transgender and then she wasnt
and while i still do its also like. completely fine to not have a transgender character :joy_wolf:

esp bc like, its not like owl house was trying to exclude lgbt rep or anything it was one of the best shows to do so

3 Likes

My understanding was that people head-canoned Frankie as trans, Dana shut that down, and people combined the speed of her doing that with “she deleted a tweet where she criticized Disney for not airing the Moon Girl episode about a character being trans” to say she was being transphobic.

1 Like

that just like tumblr drama where like, there was 0 issue but people made one up and got mad

3 Likes

Granted, I’m, like, a fifth-hand source at best, so take “the speed” and “shut that down” with wobbling levels of utility.

3 Likes

but yeah. the woke mob is going to cancel knights of guinivere. sorry.

2 Likes

ill cancel the woke mob before that happens
dana terrace my beloved

2 Likes

The thing I was considering is that unlike TADC’s main cast of 7, KoG only really has three people they can sell merch for.
Gaslight District got greenlit with a main cast of 4 and similar levels of interest, which is why I’m not too worried about KoG, but it’s a consideration.

My understanding is that extremely roughly, 1 second of animation is $1,000. A minute is $60,000, and a 25 minute episode is about $1.5 million. From there, you need a voice cast, administrative management, marketing, etc. I’m gonna hand-wave and call that $500,000 in total.
So each episode needs to make at least $2 million from merch sales to be worth making.

2 Likes

Further estimation: the average KoG merch thing looks to be about $25?
You’ve gotta convince people to buy at least 80,000 things for an episode to make its money back. And you’ve gotta be certain that you can sell another 80,000 things for every episode after that one.
There’s definitely an argument for “if the first episode sells well enough, it can offset later episodes not being able to sell as well”, but there’s a steep drop-off between a pilot and an episode 2 + 3 in viewership that you’d be fighting against from base level.

This is all me thinking out loud a bit. Closest comparable in my mind is anime being created to market and thus sell the underlying manga/light novel.

2 Likes

rubberross is an excellent animator and the show looks appealing

i dont know if i really care much for the setting/concept. obviously it gets a chance but I guess contrasting you i am someone who tadc basically immediately hooked and this doesn’t seem to have the same sauce

2 Likes