April Showers Forlorn - Day 1 (10/10)

Forum Games Ongoing
,
#181

do you guys have each other roles

#182

no

#183

unless im too blind to see it

#184

wait can you clarify here

like I understand last game, you all thought deadchat was safe from anticlaim, which is how mafia got all your claims

but dia seemed to claiming that their role makes them specifically immune to anticlaim (and assumed you would be too), not that the neighborhood chat is immune from anticlaim?

1 Like
#185

Yes I’m not a fan of town’s general sentiment that dia is “towny” for “outing the hood” first.

I’ve been in many games. People don’t kill people for being wrong in Forum Mafia. And you definitely shouldn’t because being wrong happens literally all the time. The idea that a wolf would be scared of being wrong and being killed for it doesn’t make any sense to me.

Nothing stops them from magically “re-evaluating” when they’ve killed their victim, or pushing for both their hood members (+2 mislynches, in a 10p that’s 4 dead townies in a wolf dia world).

Nothing says town will even suspect them for being wrong with their theory, they could just get away with killing one person and then deciding they were wrong and just not killing the other one. I’m not saying they’re wrong - it’s a lead at least and something to follow.

While this sounds like I’m suspecting dia - and to an extent I am - I’m more interested in discrediting people who are blindly claiming dia is somehow innocent for outing 2 other peoples’ abilitties even with good intentions. I’d be willing to bet a wolf is more than down to clown with “oh yeah that makes sense lets follow them” followed by “omg you were wrong you must be evil!” afterwards

3 Likes
#186

oh

#187

wait i don’t want this to seem like im fishing but

is the hood like someone’s role or is it random

1 Like
#188

for the record, I think it’s just me

#189

dia’s exact words were “all neighbors are immune to anticlaim”

2 Likes
#190

I have quoted another player that echoed the same sentiment

2 Likes
#191

if it’s someone’s role it is not mine

carbonated was there first but that seemed to be entirely by virtue of checking the role dm first

1 Like
#192

idt dia is towny for outing that

2 Likes
#193

how do you know it’s immune to anticlaim

#194

It was in fact me too that felt that way

but feeling that way is wrong!!!

2 Likes
#195

chomps was talking about beancat though, not dia? sorry if I missed it

#196

i’ve claimed like 90% of my role and the other 10% isn’t useful to claim even with anticlaim immunity

1 Like
#197

oh

#198

claim

is it the “you are part of a neighborhood” part

#199

some would even say it is -EV but not really

#200

dia do you want to clarify