Blood on the Forums XX - Mathematician Hell - Signups (10/15 + 2)

Forum Games Completed
,
#202

Every role had a dead ability

#203

EVERY ROLE
DO YOU KNOW HOW MANY ABILITIES INJEEDED TO MAKE?
PEOPPE COMPLAINED WHEN I POST FIXED SOME OF THE AVILITIES MID GAME CAUSE BLEED/POSIOM MEANT TO BE SAME MECH
PHSYICIAN DEAD ABILITY WAS supposed to heal BOTH not just bleed!

1 Like
#204

Huh. Yeah, thatā€™s terrible.

#205

Back then the review was basically a council of people and you pitched your idea to them and they approved or deny
It wasnā€™t a review

1 Like
#206

they approved it and my god

#207

Have you considered running a game where the scumteam controls what every flip looks like? Global forger.
(Donā€™t do this.)

1 Like
#208

I love how thereā€™s two yes but donts

And then just fucking cult leader

1 Like
#209

Cult leader

The townsfolk that absolutely got released before it was ready

1 Like
#210

Iā€™m sorry, allow me to ruin it further.
ā€œRecluse registering as evil for wincon.ā€

#211

Cult Leaderā€™s in a weird place for me, honestly. I feel like it should have a similar niche to Snake Charmer, where it can receive completely accurate information with a sort of risk, but the win condition aspect is weird and doesnā€™t really pair up well with the alignment change except as a bandaid fix. I donā€™t know if CL is meant to go on a script with Heretic, but if it is, that feels kinda terrible. I definitely think it needs to go on a script around it.

#212

See, that niche you proposed can be observed more clearly on the Moneylender (which literally just chooses a player each night to turn into their alignment)

I think the Cult Leader is meant to be used for the wincon. Butā€¦ the best time to actually fire it is really weird.
And no itā€™s definitely not meant to be paired with Heretic, they used to be jinxed at one point :wowee:

Soā€¦ you make a script around this thingā€¦ and what? If the win condition is the focal point, then good probably just has the tools to outright solve the game in the first place anyway, no need for a cult.

1 Like
#213

Scripts arent real

1 Like
#214

Soundslike it has a decent amount of sudoku to do which I appreciate

1 Like
#215

But I donā€™t have enough experience with BotC/BotF to have an opinion on a script without playing it, I havenā€™t ever seen half these characters in practice before, who knows how the hell they interact. You know?

#216

Atheist/Heretic works better.

#217

This sounds like a terrible character unless thereā€™s more to what you just said, kinda. Confirm a load of good players, and if you ever turn evil itā€™s fine if you survive a night.

#218

I hard disagree unless thereā€™s a saint in the game. If good ever believes itā€™s an Atheist game, they have to stall it out past F3 anyway. Itā€™s boring.

#219

I think Lunatic!May would be entertaining, wouldnā€™t you agree?

1 Like
#220

Trust me it is a terrible character :skull:

#221

Is it homebrew?