BoTF XIII.1 Grave Digging and Filling Day Six (Final Day) Evil Win

Forum Games Completed
,
#2821

/Nominate Night
/Execute Night @Host_Account_4

#2822

Is there a reason it’s better to execute and hope we’re right than try to go for a mayor win?

#2823

Also is there a reason Night would try to protect my claim until now, as a wolf? (I don’t really know what’s optimal in that situation but I thought it would make more sense for her to just push me and try to execute me yesterday)

#2824

Wind, how many evils do you think are alive?

#2825

If your answer is more than 1, then tomorrow evils will have parity and will be able to execute anyone, because Whysper (The presumed minion) still has their vote token.

#2826

I have no idea
I assume Whysper was a minion but Egg is only a minion if Magnus is the demon, I think
And that’s exactly in one world and no others
So then we’d have two evils in play and it would be between Magnus/Night/Amelia? Who am I forgetting?

#2827

But you’re saying it’s a 50-50 shot today and a guaranteed loss tomorrow?

#2828

I’m saying that we haven’t done merely enough executing to guarentee that the number of evils alive tomorrow will be 1.

For all intents and purposes, today is the last day we have to execute someone, specifically the demon, before we like lose.

Unless you can provide a world where two minions have died, I’m sticking with the “We’re all gonna dieeeeee!” view.

#2829

The only world in which two minions are dead is Whysper/Egg minion and Magnus demon, with one of the minions being poisoner
Possibly Whysper poisoner, Magnus SW and Egg demon

#2830

But yeah those three are the only ones that can be evil together and result in both minions being dead

#2831

Actually
There doesn’t have to be a poisoner if Egg was demon and Magnus was SW, does there? That still fits correctly with Atlas’s info? Or does the demon have to die at night and not to execution?

#2832

And

So do all the dead Good players?

#2833

Well we know for sure that Whysper is definitely an evil, and possibly a Poisoner if we trust Magnus’ claim.
Egg might’ve been a ravenkeeper, again if we trust Magnus’ claim.

#2834

If you trust those claims then I’m a demon

#2835

Or I guess Night can also be
But idk why she defended me yesterday then cause it wouldn’t have mattered whether Egg or I flipped

#2836

“flipped” as in got executed
I keep forgetting this is botf

#2837

Looking at the history of whispers, it actually looks plausible that a minion Night could’ve learned that you were a Mayor but then never got another chance to tell Magnus in private.

#2838

But in this world we assume that Magnus would have read the thread competently enough to make good enough kills, but did not show it in-thread

#2839

I mean
I outright told Night I was a mayor

#2840

I think that’s actually a possibility