Cookie Thread Act 1: A Cookie in Time

It is only slightly better than cop13 in my book

1 Like

terrible turbo setup just run joat10

Champs loves their shittily designed 15ps so this isn’t even the worst 15p I’ve seen designed
Yes you are right though that this is significantly townsided because mafia’s ā€œcounterplayā€ options to PRs don’t even counterplay them. It is objectively correct to put roleblocker instead of jailkeeper on mafia it’s so fucking weird why they didn’t make that choice
PRs being excessively durable if they claim on the correct day is unreasonable…but jailkeeper hitting mafia after outing itself is just a big oof tbh

2 Likes

11v2 is the optimal balance point for mountainous

2 Likes

Consider, however, that 11v2 mountainous is fucking terrible

1 Like

But yes

Standard numbers are:
11v2
12v3
15v4

iirc

2 Likes

Genuinely all this setup needs is 1, maybe 2 shot roleblocker instead of the scum 1-shot jailkeeper

2 Likes

2 pr 15p 12v3 is already the ā€œā€œidealā€ā€ balance of mafia needing to miselim 50% of non-pr town

2 Likes

I think this is a huge design trap because the optimal form of the 2 pr 15p 12v3 is

named townie
named townie
vt 10x
mafia goon 3x

2 Likes

Anything else you give town can actively jeopardize that balance

1 Like

geyde is like the gordon ramsay of mafia setups i adore reading them talking shit about everything (i read their posts in gordon ramsay’s voice too) its too good

3 Likes

The best basic bitch mafia setup is vig10

1 Like

Unironically

2 Likes

i like to think of geyde as the saul goodman of mafia

2 Likes

We’re like 250 posts off right

God what the fuck am I supposed to talk about I was sure I’d start ranting about something when I made the initial questionpost

1 Like

chupie

1 Like

chupie

the only role I want to run a serious game designed around is mafia drug dealer (can give a player any feedback they wish)

1 Like

The issue with constructing something around this monstrosity is that it’s blatantly a terrible

1 Like