Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

General
#22353

ironically i think my biggest blunder was pushing through the execution on the cannibal but i thought we had a shot at the 2 good exes world

#22354

if there isn’t someone else dead when i get executed they don’t solve

#22355

Character development, baby!

#22356

Nah, you played well.
I should’ve realized you were my ally and killed [other person].

#22357

you’ve learned to fakeclaim as Good, now you just need to be able to do it as evil,,

#22358

i genuinely forgot that the world in which they were widow just. completely contradicted my artist info. so i just completely ignored that

#22359

I mean, my Amnesiac fake was quite good in that I played it exactly how I would’ve played as an Amnesiac.

#22360

hey the amne fake almost got him through! (because i was the only one who knew how amne worked and deliberately didn’t challenge it)

#22361

Oh, yeah, how does the Amnesiac role work?

#22362

i heard him be like “oh i asked and i’m not the cannibal” and i was just like “oh i’m gonna have to pretend that amne is a random on-script role for the rest of the game aren’t i”

#22363

the storyteller can give you literally any ability they want. no matter how insane

#22364

it doesn’t have to have any precedent. and you get to guess what it is!

#22365

for the record if you were actually an investigator you would’ve totally been prompted to choose people and get results, even if you didn’t know what those results meant. so i winced when you said you got a warm on that

#22366

its important when youre randing digital BOTC to state which player wouldve been handed the bag first and last, that way erach player knows how much agency they WOULDVE had when picking their role

its also imporatnt to re-rack during this stage, and cliam that “a player pulled out two tokes at once and saw both so now we have to restart bc they have extra info”. it adds to the realism

4 Likes
#22367

I mean, that was not the reason I got caught (I got caught on something; would love to know what that something was).

#22368

Also, gummy and [other person] were talking through night, so I was hoping Arete would intervene or something.

#22369

you got caught because they figured out that i was widow and pushing a little too hard for the savant poisoned world

#22370

Real

1 Like
#22371

yeah i was a little annoyed when they were just solving the game during night phase. they shouldn’t be able to do that, that’s what day phase is for!

1 Like
#22372

Ah.
Ok, that makes sense.