Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

Wait was this the JK9er game

For reference the Jailkeeper. Game I’m talking about is uh
the drafting game
Jailkeeper is super strong which is why I chose it

1 Like

and we executed a mafia d1 which is just really painful in that setup depending upon PR’s

1 Like

Apparently no one chose cop tho

1 Like

The top pick chose neigborizer

how can you talk down on jailkeeper leafia

2 Likes

didney worl

1 Like

Right

the first game to upgrade fancy play syndrome from a nickname for stupid shit to an actual mental illness

3 Likes

lmao sometimes our circuit runs a draft based setup. every time mafia has the first overall pick they choose cop even though it’s entirely useless for them because obviously a townie would choose cop with the first pick. and then every time a townie has the first pick they don’t choose cop without fail

2 Likes

why don’t they just take BPV

1 Like

we have a pretty different draft list. but there is a bomb that mafia has to be wary of

2 Likes

also gunsmith has gone to mafia literally every time it’s been run. i inherently distrust gunsmith claims

1 Like

why not run pgo like normal people

1 Like

our draft list is fucking weird now that i think about it

2 Likes

you would think that since fruit vendor is mechanically useless no one would ever pick it. and yet

2 Likes

every time i see draft games ran the villagers just pick the funny roles and not the strong roles

which is the only reason those setups arent horribly townsided, probably, but

1 Like

@arete didnt like 6 people try to pick fruit vendor/neighborizer in the CD game or something

2 Likes

our town first overall picks have been
bomb (reasonable)
neighborizer (??)
conversationalist (imagine neighborizer but with 1 on 1 neighborhoods that only last for a day phase) (???)
two-shot strongman vig (reasonableish, fucked over the mafia)

1 Like

our mafia first overall picks have exclusively been cop

1 Like