FAM5 - Thread 5 - Day 4

[Atlas]

i believe you, i was just curious

i said various times she just gets annoyed when pushed as town and is perfectly fine as scum

[Magnus]

…I don’t think that assessment is entirely correct. Leafia can grow incensed at being suspected as evil she’s knuckled into a corner.

[Atlas]

she was wild when the first person did it

[Magnus]

The Sulit case was unnecessarily prolonged, and if there was something additional on d1… I don’t think I’ve ever taken the first few accusations as a cue for reading Leafia, specifically. Hmm.

Oh right, I remember.
I thought Leafia scumslipped. That’s why I voted her. Sorry.

[Atlas]

it’s just waiting for the blackjack event to end

[Magnus]

@Luka

@neil_the_eel @chloe can you guys vote amelia

@nutella

i voted amelia before but why now

@Luka

theyre a viable cw and theyve still had huge resistance all day

@nutella

idk im probably staying on apo the claim is just >rand wolf and shes not done anything towny

Nutella has decent socials; the only way I can build this in my head is if Nutella committed to bussing Apo, which I suppose could exist for a gladiator wolf role but I feel like that’s one ability which would dissuade forthcoming suspicion — and the check about ending days voting wolves is an intricate claim with spew potential because it just encourages Nutella to join major wagons — this has been a consistent, and reasonable, behaviour.

---

@Mistyx

i might be tunneling on apo nutella w/w

whatever ill leave it be 4 now

@nutella

i think i would commit more to either bussing or not if we were w/w it should be clear i just don’t know

[Magnus]

I feel like I’m doing the same thing in the last BotC game wherein as evil I just townread anyone who could be executed over me, or that it looks like I’m doing that.

[Magnus]

@Memekingpizza

Rememebr when I said I wasn’t going to wall post…oops. But overall I think hero is just making some calls in bad faith so it probably da mafia among us out of alot.

Summary

#323 This post seems that any student council member gets elected as a higher chance of mafia. But the thing is we know mafia is the minority so if we pooled votes or if they decide to give it to town we would just kill them. It could be a setup or them telling us what’s going to happen.

#1864 Trying to shade Leafia due them knowing someone else because of a passive. But the thing is this is day one information and I would honestly believe it. But I guess if the person is mafia Leafia is as well. But I doubt that is the case to make a play this early into the game.

#1891 It’s just like a nightwatchman but the thing is evil can just hide it and pretend it never exists. So they are either paired or both town. Bad faith or overly paranoid I would never know.

#2036 I don’t think this is reasonable due to the fact it was rng’d so if it landed on an evil oh well it basically never gets outed since hard confirming in this type of setup is few a far between so I’m willing to take it as faith. So I think this is trying to set up night kills on them for town killing power.

#2343 Being nice to someone is a good way to pocket because if they aren’t trusted and are town giving them someone to seem reliable is an easy way to do so. It’s hard to change someone’s mind when someone sees you in a positive light inside of a game.

#2390 Pinged in mafia chat about the event and inned just to be in there for a chance to get the prize for their team

#5287 Your reasoning was based on game design but is that really a reason. It could just be a town confirming another town that needs it due to their rolecard.

#5349 Then try to do something about it besides say it. You have power with your vote if the thread is being controlled by mafia use your actions to defy them. I feel you are just saying this for one of two reasons when it’s revealed that is was being controlled you look like town or town is just talking and talking and mafia are on the back foot.

#6345 tmi or it has happened in previous mashes. I wouldn’t know because I didn’t check the last fam mafia chat if it was posted.

---

@Kork

@Memekingpizza

Okay I’m back for reals this time. No lies. So at this moment in time from the time I was doing other things. Based on the board I want to trust Ruby/Kork at the moment. Ruby is doing simillar things from previous games and it seems geniune for now. In another mash I have played with them they are doing the exact same things and they were town. Kork is playing passive from at the moment with the King title so I’m inclined to trust them but I have only one game with them that I recall.

last day me and ruby just felt like meme was off is all, not really hardcore think he’s wolf

@Kork

There isn’t really a specific message that stands out, but the main thing for me is that from when I play social deduction games with him he usually is a lot more aggressive but seemed way too passive, but tbf it could be just be because the whole idea about fam in general.

---

@Memekingpizza

@nutella

i put her in the lead before and i’d do it again

I don’t like this wanting it to randVOTE: Apocryphal it seems pairing

@Memekingpizza

The way it turned from a tie vote into a tipped scale towards a party seems either we have a mafia on the block or a mafia decided to ping the chat to move it off of them for an extra day.

@Memekingpizza

These votes swings are going to make me lose years of my life. After the pigon vote swing it felt like apo was evil and heres another swing into apo this might be town rising up against the mafia captors or it’s just been v/v this entire time and we sob.

@Memekingpizza

@soweli

pizza is acting too clueless i don’t like it (i.e. think he’s wolfy), don’t really like lukeh flashwagon too many iffy slots there

This looks like a push to save apo. We were confident based on the votes that any counter wagon to save them got traction. I’m not going crazy about that.

MKP was flimsier on the first day, doesn’t have a good reason to join the Apo wagon (never mentioned Apo previously) then grows deeply invested — and was suspected by the two people who knew him best.

[Atlas]

@Magnus

and was suspected by the two people

who’s the non kork person

[Atlas]

ruby trs him

[Daeron]

I am back

Oh my god those ITAs are horrific
can we please stop killing villagers and instead investigate “”“towncore”""

[Daeron]

why was pigeon shot
pigeon was spewed V by carroty
I said this before

[Daeron]

Soweli & sulit ITAing retro also looks terrible

[Wazza]

never wanted to win blackjack anyway tbh

[Daeron]

We are not hanging Silviu

I am shielding them

[Wazza]

do you at least have better reasoning than Atlas

[Atlas]

my reasoning is fine you just fail to comprehend that it is just that easy

[Daeron]

It’s a 15v8 right now, assuming 25% scum

[Daeron]

I don’t need to justify any reasoning to you
I have been right on every occasion except Wisdom & Pqwerty, which I re-evaluated right after shooting them

[Atlas]

what