Same question for you, @jason.mrrown.
Meow remains my strongest townread.
Willow hasnāt progressed but more people have townread them (you and daeron) so I think they can continue to be a townlean in my book
You and daeron I feel neutral about but both of you have been active about making reads and posting so I expect Iāll be able to find you later on.
That leaves a pool of carbon / gummy / zoe / marluna / pandora / hazard / leafia
Leafia specifically hasnāt been active at all
2 Likes
townlean barring sorta bastard mech?: marluna
neutral-townlean: ash / jason
neutral-slight-townlean: hazard / willow / pandora / zoe
neutral : gummy / daeron / carbon
[existing probably neutral]: leafia
disclaimer: āOne makes oneās little judgmentsābut nine times out of ten one is wrongā + historically my d1 reads are like. random levels, so really I should be metagaming myself and looking for 1 mafia in each of [neutral], [neutral-slight-townlean], [neutral-townlean+townlean] probably, but thatās not helpful bc obviously Iām not going to be able to differentiate between them.
Iām not very happy with the neutral tier bc it def feels too āeasyā ā Iām just picking everyone who hasnāt posted a ton or hinted about their roles which never actually works as a heuristic
also I still havenāt backread yesterday really, so these might get updated but probably just in that people get moved up 
2 Likes
same reasoning for my willow read, insane
2 Likes
Edit: i forgot hazard also townread willow
1 Like
Out of curiosity, what makes you put Hazard/Pandora above Daeron/Carbon?
1 Like
tf is ash saying im mafia
i couldnāt parse his longpost
BRO
YOU THINK MAFIA ME WOULD SAY KILL MEOW KILL MEOW KILL MEOW
1 Like
im crashing out
how are you always wrong on me
literally the way to read me is to read what ash says about me and flip it
ā¦this isnāt a response to my argument.
i donāt even know what your argument is
also why would i respond to something so patently false
Iām arguing that t!you exhibits more drive to solve the game as a means of understanding and parsing it while w!you feels no such urge and thus is far more confident in their reads and posts.
hazard and pandora both said stuff about their roles, so I am automatically inclined to believe theyāre more likely to be town
annoyingly hazardposting has generally felt more likely to be town than pandoraās, but I find it more plausible to imagine mafia being like āmy role is a role of all timeā (or something) vs. āmy role is strong but sucksā and then updating it to āsucks but strongā
anyway, everyone in that tier is basically someone who has casually mentioned something about their role + has townreads on them from other players
1 Like
If you want to dispute my argument, we can discuss that, but I do feel Iāve been rather clear about my arguments here.
gummy!
itās d1 my dude
i hasnāt been halfway into d1
i have an exam on monday
YOURE ALSO JUST WRONG
the only read ive made is that jason feels very towny ??? which ya he does
heās been asking questions that i would expect of town jason, and as far as i know his wolf game and town game are pretty polarized which is why i was OKAY making that read
thereās nothing that heās posted afterwards that would make me take it back anyways
youāre like reaching really hard
you also donāt know my meta; mafia me lets people carry everything for her and i even like. donāt push people hard as mafia until after a couple of days ;(
1 Like
does he townread you when you are mafia
yes
see: odyssey
1 Like
like in cheesings ash was convinced i was mafia until mafia killed me and flipped town
and im pretty sure he was convinced i was mafia in upick too??
i was town in both ;(