Grande Idea - Endgame - Mafia wins

Forum Games Completed
,
#621

genuinely unsure how that happened but my brain was just thinking about how weak townies die all the time, and I guess the wires from town and die got crossed somehow

never really realized weak was opposite alignment I think?

1 Like
#622

Ok i’m still not getting it can you spell it out for me sorry

1 Like
#623

like okay i fully admit this is bullshit and arguably weaker than the marluna thing but i want to explain it anyways because brain tinges

  1. a weak townie is a townie that dies when they visit mafia. can also be extrapolated to be opposite alignment, which accomplishes the same thing, but is technically more generally applicable and people can explain it that way if they want
  2. therefore, a weak mafia would be a mafia that dies when they visit town. this is not a role that would appear in any game, BUT
  3. meow was talking about how they don’t think they die when they visit town, in response to me calling them weak
  4. a weak mafia would die when they visit town. a weak town would not
  5. meow was referring to themselves. therefore, perspective slip
#624

willow is arguing that I am mafia who slipped this when my thought process of “weak” => “town” since opposite alignment

#625

okay this is arguably more suspicious

#626

Are you saying that w!meow got confused and thought weak roles visit that of the opposite alignment and accidentally wolfslipped

#627

anyways im submitting a weak mafia jailkeeper to the GI thread after this game ends

2 Likes
#628

yea that’s the gist

#629

as mentioned I don’t think this actually makes very much sense its just something i noticed

#630

frankly if anything this is suspect

#631

which part?

#632

just the general feeling the need to retroactively justify a scumslip that wasn’t an actual scumslip ig?
like, i was very open about not actually thinking this makes sense
and honestly that explanation looks way more like “mafia did say that thinking of it that way and needs to come up with a town justification”
the reason it isn’t a scumslip is because it doesn’t actually mean you’re mafia, it just is a thought process that mafia Could have

#633

i very mucg believe town!you could and would say that on accident, especially given the hoops required to get there
i think it less likely that was what town!you was legitimately thinking
weak townies don’t die all the time!! the most common example is weak masonizer, which honestly gets folded into the fact that you can’t masonize a mafia member anyways

#634

I am having a minor crisis right now upon this being outlined and discovering I have cognitive dissonance about what weak means:

  1. weak means dying when you visit mafia to me. [lengthy overexplanation is that weak townies in qbcord almost 100% suicide n1 onto a mafia, so they’re just. associated with dying for me I guess]
  2. but I also believe that a mafia weak doc can only heal mafia?

upon further analysis, it is possible I conflated all the mafia weak doc fakeclaims into an actual mafia role

you’re telling me it just meant opposite alignment this entire time I need to update my mafia terminology doc tomorrow…

#635

well
it literally never actually appears on mafia
that’d be like having a town godfather
but it’s just a way that someone could explain it to you

1 Like
#636

and yea that would be considered a mafia Loyal doctor here so

1 Like
#637

oh my god i forgot about qbcord

#638

I think I would have just not focused on it if it was an actual slip and hoped it blew over. I was baffled myself about how I had that thought process in the first place, thus the exploration

1 Like
#639

nah i doubt it

#640

some people maybe but
the Vibes man
the Vibws