I think I might be the Goblin - EVIL WIN

Jarek claimed plague doctor to me

Jarek seems to have claimed different things to everyone.

Hippo is almost certainly evil then

This whole sequence of events literally happened after hippo asked zone if they should be still doing their plan

I currently think the demon is either Zone or Ash

And its confirmed that kir cannot have been demon yes

1 Like

Again, why do it?
Zone wasn’t on the chopping block, and I was being removed from the chopping block.

Because they formed a plan at the beginning, they whispered each other first

Either hippo was trying to save you or he was trying to do a plan they came up together with Zone

And what does that plan accomplish?
Outing yourself for “random confusion” doesn’t make sense.

Can you think of a single accomplishment that plan would have had in any world? Besides you being demon?

Evils aren’t rational people. You looked at the night kills like evils were mad scientists dissecting the kill when in reality they are Patrick with a hammer

Exactly.
And me and Hippo being W/W does not make sense for previously established reasons.
This is why I’m hesitating on w!Hippo.

Esp in botc when they have no idea what’s going on

I’m not saying that everything there was rational.
I’m saying that there was no reason at all for Hippo to do that, even if I were the Demon.
And I know both that I am not and that there are clear reasons why it can’t be me and Hippo.

If hippo isn’t evil we have already lost again

Unless there’s no damsel and jarek is evil ducking with us

Put “we have already lost” aside.
That has done us no good so far.

We still must try and solve.

I think it’s very fair to assume we lost if hippo isn’t evil based off how everyone has reacted to the damsel claim