To be clear I did this because I was at a party and drunk and my phone kept vibrating
Chomps has nominated Jarek.
VOTE: Jarek
UNVOTE
VOTE: JarekVOTE: Ash
Current Votecount
| Nominator | Nominee | # | Voters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chariot | BetterMittens | 0 | |
| BetterMittens | Ash | 2 | Zone_Q11, Chomps |
| Jarek | Chomps | 0 | |
| Chomps | Jarek | 1 | Chomps |
| — | |||
| Not Voting | 7 | Kiiruma, Jarek, Ash, Hippopablompoyeetus, BetterMittens, carbonated, Chariot |
Ash (2): Zone_Q11, Chomps
Jarek (1): Chomps
Not Voting (7): Kiiruma, Jarek, Ash, Hippopablompoyeetus, BetterMittens, carbonated, Chariot
Zone how on earth could you actually think Im a minion I cant tell if youre bluffing right now
I feel i should clear a few things up about my play yesterday as while i dont mind some heat i think its currently detrimental to town
Yeah perfect this means you are drunk and BetterMittens is evil
Alright. I’ve heard some more evidence that points towards the demon being between Chomp/Ash, which I will not share, but will put that out there. One of those players should be our execution today, I’ll try to figure out which one is most likely to be the demon.
Hippo hasn’t provided an actual reason for their behavior, instead opting to just act in utter disbelief that people think they are evil, which confirms that they are probably just evil. I think they are either the Goblin or The Boffin, or they could be the No Dashii going through Moth (Chariot) towards me. Either way, I don’t think we ever kill them today. Moth could also be the No Dashii poisoning me. I think those are the only worlds where my information has been tampered with. Knowing the information I do now, Hippo/Moth can be the demon only if the demon is a No Dashii, Jarek/Zone can’t be the demon, which leaves Chomp/Ash as the demon barring No Dashii worlds.
I’ll go through their ISO’s in more depth after, I’m more so spilling out my thoughts here to help organize my thoughts now that I’m medicated.
I think the main argument for Chomp being the demon is that for them to be a villager, they would have to have checked Hippo and then read the thread after getting their information, instead of reading the thread and then deciding to use their action. It’s weird that Chomp only read the thread after they got their information that Hippo was evil. Hippo was also the safest person for Demon!Chomp to check. Chomp has also been voting their green check for multiple days in a row (they did change to ash) even after they said they were probably the sober one. Chomps’s first whisper was also with Hippo, but it’s sort of confusing as to why Hippo would claim amnesiac if Chomp had bluffs. I wouldn’t put it past Hippo to claim amnesiac just cause they wanted to and it would line up if Hippo was the goblin.
The main arguments of the top of my head for Ash being evil is the fact that Hippo started fo freak out and distract town when Ash/Kiiruma were on the block. In this world, Hippo would have whispered Ash and decided to fake Pixie and double claiming Ash, which would line up with Ash not commenting much on the double claim itself to Zone confusion. Hippo would have claimed mutant to try to swing the thread against Kiiruma and then Damsel guess in order to avoid losing the game.
Both of these worlds line up with all the information currently in the game. It’s just a matter of figuring out which of these, if either, is correct
1 Like
I don’t think it can be a Xann 1 because most information seems to be correct night one. The only information we cannot hard confirm as correct night one is myself and it makes little sense to put in a minion that removes an outsider just to poison one person’s information. Which means we are dealing with two outsiders. I think Chomp is the mutant and Ash is the Imp. Chomp being the mutant would explain why they checked Hippo and why they voted me despite green checking us. I think the mechanical evidence suggests that Ash is most likely to be the demon out of everyone here.
Ash being the Imp would also explain why they were trying to make it seem as though Hippo was not outted, because it would suck for them to starpass later.
There are worlds where Kiiruma is the mutant adhering to madness even though they are dead, they have outright stated they would do this even if it would cost them the game. I don’t think it’s worth discussing right now though.
I think that about covers the mechanical side. I’ve looked through all the mechanics with all the information given to me.
Taking a look back at Ash again, part of why I backed off before backing back on after May talked to me and me learning new information was the way they weren’t bending at all when I pushed them. I find that wolves tend to bend a little because they don’t know the exact way to handle my energy as town or sporadicalness and he kept pretty much kept pushing his world against me in a way that I’m used to seeing from town. But also, may brought up the fact that Ash usually is more cautious and hesitant about their reads when they are wolfing. And also reading back through their posts, it felt as soon as the day started they had a plan that revolves around the night kill to “frame” me. And reading back through the hippo stuff, I just don’t see why hippo would do that unless they actually cared about what was happening which makes me think it’s just ash
You are an absolute politician of WIM. Ill give you that.