Last poster before threadlock gets a cookie (cookie thread (Part 7)) (Part 11)

Paige is also the staple support and she still stings, same as Rem, same as anyone else. Ever took an ice cannon on full spirit from Kelvin?

Actually, did you have lobbies where Rem just goes full gun build?

…no.

Kelvin isn’t ever built as support really
nor do I think he’s meant to be an actual healer

I have more issues with the physics of everything (motive etc. aside) but I don’t appreciate the game specifically going out of its way to give me info I did not ask for or need, clarify that they really mean it and are not mistaken, and then have that info be false

which i think is a very fair complaint

like

most of the fun of a mystery game is in trying to solve a mystery, and it becomes way harder to do that if I cannot trust the info the game is telling me is a fact to be a fact

2 Likes

if Kelvin wants to annoy you to death they build 3

my legs gave out can someone carry me

Sure, maybe he’s a blend, but his entire gimmick is slowing you down

i think its reasonable to assume that the info could indeed have been wrong, but in that case why are you bringing it up at all??? just literally dont mention it or be like ā€œidkā€ and at least the mystery is then not actively misleading (in a frustrating way, not in a good way)

1 Like

that’s what I said yes

his gimmick isn’t full support/healing it’s debuffing and trapping

How was it deduced that Maki’s deduction was wrong? Or did they only realize it when they realized the seesaw effect was a thing?

1 Like

if i cant trust the game to tell me facts as facts and state opinions as opinions, there isn’t much I can do to solve any of these mysteries because you can just write whatever you want and i have no basis for truth to try and build a solve from

to be clear i think the implication is ā€œshe didn’t die instantly, but owing to the stab wound in her neck she didn’t have the time or ability to like. actually do anything about it.ā€

By that sense, what do you think of Paige?

Paige is more support but she can have a semi similar gimmick
I’d argue she’s an area control who also heals/buffs allies

it was never acknowledged that my lie, which apparently is Just What Actually Happened, was in fact meant to be a lie

so we never ever touched on it being wrong

which imo is just bad design

1 Like

hey as a reminder to all of you try to spoil everything that’s actually spoilers several of you have openly spoiled who the killer isn’t, who’s alive, chapter 1 twists, etc

3 Likes

that’s fine but again in what case why ever mention it???

i again assume its just a translation thing but I will take any amount of ā€œwell that seems incredibly farfetchedā€ elements over ones where the game goes out of its way to tell me something is definitely true, that in actuality I need to completely reject to solve the case (it would be okay if it was a lie from a culprit, but it’s not!!!)

the former makes a mystery silly/dumb, the latter makes me wonder why I’m even thinking about your ā€œmysteryā€ at all

1 Like

Well the only thing she does that is buffside is the shield and that’s it.

…her ult also buffs. I’m not saying Kelvin and Paige aren’t pretty much the same niche I’m saying you can expect Kelvin to hurt a lot more than harrow