Well you should have protected the Marshal instead, and if you really are Herbalist and missed the part where he said he was bleeding, then that’s a skill issue on your part.
Other than the fact that the first Arbiter gets to choose their successor, there is nothing that sets them apart. Second Arbiter gets to fake their own class upon promotion, so everything really is the same.
not a skill issue its an irl issue, i was busy last day i couldn’ read anything, couldn’t do anything
plus if i was an evil i’d def claim the visit on sayno rather than getting hazard confirmed and putting myself under the bus for nothing
at least i would thunderdome me and hazard, i would have a chance to kill hazard there
now instead hazard is %99 unseen and you are voting me
how did claiming to have visited rowen benefit me so far zone?
please do not let achro and carbon get away with it, at least give me a chance
That’s only possible if we have a… an Angel. In other words, beancat’s only “not first Arbiter” if Derps framed beancat at N1, which… is stretching a lot. That’s just reaching too far into the possibilities; the evils would have to somehow know of this or otherwise it would be like the stars aligning to give beancat the worst luck possible.
Duke please, if you are not throwing execute me TONIGHT. i don’t want you to waste a day on me
im starting to think achro is the duke tbh, this play would only come from an afk player i guess?
Right, the only possible conclusion is Herbalist.
If beancat is forged into arbiter then Hazard is 100% town since the first arbiter didnt die. Bro got bussed hard
If Beancat is first arbiter then Hazard being arbiter that faked visit to Sayno to heal supposed bleed from him so he get to die tomorrow and kill somebody else entirely, presuming the duke isnt converted then they kill Hazard the same night.
But if Canping flips arbiter then there is no way hazard is evil.
I am also retracting this statement because I forgot there was a world where Kiiruma is Socialite. Still wouldn’t explain the third visit that jail saw, so Kii’s probably still Unseen, but I now have one reliable reason less to believe Kii is confirmed Unseen.
The website is getting laggy to my end, I had to refresh 
this is probably the most likely what happened, hazard needs to heal sayno again tonight
IDK, and frankly I’m not going to answer that question. “Why would evil do stupid stuff?” is not a question that should be answered.
im not saying hazard is the second arbiter
No, he proclaimed he is not duke, also you should stop rolefishing who is duke, I figured it out.
you need think about or else you will waste a day on me, basically ignoring achro or carbon here
Last time someone (Frost) said “don’t let … get away” I made a choice that killed lemon the Judge. I am not going to do anything this time.
Wrong. If Duke is not throwing, then they’d have already outed themselves by Yesterday.
They are throwing by not doing that AND by letting you live through N3. They are beyond saving.
are you aware that achro was supposed to be executed and now i am dying instead? which means you are ignoring them, why? i already presented reasons why the seond arbiter couldn’t be me
maybe, but they might not be intentionally throwing and can decide to actually kill me instead unless they are converted
Again: Still very unlikely. Like, I don’t recall Derps signalling anything at all. –well, no. Actually, I don’t remember anything from Derps.
If Hazard’s fake Herbalist, then Sayno dies Tomorrow.
Uh. This part I don’t understand.
…does everyone have reading issues?
Frost -in that paragraph- is hypothesizing a world where Hazard is Second Arbiter, and you are saying Hazard needs to heal Sayno.