To elaborate on why I feel so strongly about this read: nothing Zone_Q11 did especially stood out as “contributing a lot”, and I do not see why his vote on Amelia specifically would be something to be respected at all. It was called out as “random”. I have spoken a lot about looking for behaviour which does not make sense, which does not track as a set of decisions a villager would make, and this is one such decision. It is utterly bizarre that Frostwolf103 would suddenly gain great respect for Zone_Q11’s “random target” here. It simply does not make sense.
No, because if I am pretending I shouldnt voted Amelia in first place
Your overanalysis is less to be desired as well.
Looking back, this is true: there were real-time reactions, I had simply forgotten about them because I did not find them especially notable or alignment-indicative. I remain unconvinced, though: none of these real-time reactions seem to foreshadow any of the reads to come, being more about mechanics and things being non-alignment-indicative than anything.
9 hours have passed
flipless is Childe t game, worst is childe w game
1 Like
And i dip bye
1 Like
You do not desire me trying to read you? Do not discredit me by calling it over-analysis, it is a quite simple reading of the facts here.
Why did you not answer my question on whether you had a read on Amelia before Zone_Q11’s post? You only engaged with my posts when I began clearly actively wolfreading you.
he’s trying to say that your reads have “stuff to be desired”
esl
You did it too hard, I find it dislikable with suggestive details.
childe (4): catbae, Daeron, Atlas, ElizaThePsycho
soweli (3): Memekingpizza, Amelia, Chomps
Amelia (1): Frostwolf103
pandora (1): Zone_Q11
Frostwolf103 (1): Rhea
Not Voting (7): Kiiruma, min, soweli, pandora, Hazardwaste, childe, Kelsier
I am not exactly attentive at times, I do think Amelia is a hit. Unlike the slankers.
Argue against those details, then. Don’t just call it “overanalysis” and leave it at that.
Did you think Amelia was a hit before Zone_Q11’s vote?
No, that’s when I was doing ISO diving and put the vote there, obviously.
lol
Deal with it. It’s less of issue for me to convince you, there’s no such intricative motives behind my posts. Clearly everyone has own agendas and think about hitting a slanker might be wolf, unlike them I read through their interactions that’s more impactful than losing active player, because putting a risk in eliminating active player instead shows value on the voters, but not on a slanker wagon
Taking a step back, I feel my reaction may have been a bit quick – I do not actually really understand the kinds of mistakes Frostwolf103 would have to make as evil here. It is a similar situation to Chomps: I am not sure an evil would genuinely try to argue that Zone_Q11’s post claiming that Amelia was a literal random vote were high-effort enough to warrant sheeping, and the fact that Frostwolf103 has stood by this instead of trying to claim his read on Amelia was independent of Zone_Q11’s vote is also strange. UNVOTE for the time being – I do not necessarily see Frostwolf103 as town here, but I do not think my reasons for wolfreading him are so solid.
I unfortunately believe that I need a break from mafia at the moment, as I am still a bit out of it from the stress of last week. I apologize for having to vanish so close to the day’s end, but I do not think it wise for my health to continue playing at this time. Of the existing wagons, I do not have a strong preference – I find childe and soweli to be roughly equivalent choices, with a weak preference for childe, and I am having trouble disentangling my thoughts on Amelia from my reaction to Frostwolf103, which I do not think is objective or fair at the moment.
Apologies again.
3 Likes
i just kind of think childe is a free wolf tbh
kii is actively pinging me (something about the way he’s caught up in self defense and excuses over having real thiughts) but he can be revisited on day 2 with more info available, worse to be wrong on him on day 1
1 Like