sorry this is my first time being here since start of game and i just admitted i forgot about reading up 5 seconds ago Genuinely what do you expect me to say to this
1 Like
Wait hold up,
@Wazza, did you forget to vote tutuu or something? If not, mind giving a sentence explaining why you’re not rn?
Obviously you say that Sultan and Achro are most suspicious, because you randomly chose them in your head.
Respectable.
I vaguely remember saying tutuu was town but i wouldnt hold that very highly. btw ace is town
What we know:
- We vote to burn a book Today
- Burning a Book gives hidden information
What Wazza fears:
- Burning a “wrong Book” will give Mafia private information, rather than giving Town public information
What Zone fears:
- Burning an Unstable Book will give Town information, but also give Mafia more power
Sultan, it’s just a reads-list with a modicum amount of argument behind them.
Do you scumread EggYolk purely because of his list’s structure, or do you perhaps disagree with some of his reads? If it’s the latter, then I cannot comprehend your read on EggYolk.
Now remember, when we post high five emoji in the mafia discord server for this that using the white skin tone is weird, so just use default.
alright zone is town im ready to poe
Ace tea is good yea.
Ace is lock town, gonna townread Wazza too for the way they parsed Ace’s words. I’ll write a big post with explanations actually for everyone.
1 Like
SHIT I FORGOT TO G-
1 Like
- I did not pay much attention to your interaction with ATNo in FAM6.
- tutuu is not ATNo; Different people, different context.
1 Like
I know, I am whimsy as I go.
Not the structure but the reads themselves are very baseless they seem like ah yeah sure with little to no confidence in any if them
I do like the progression you and Zone do.
I am not going to disagree with your interpretation of EggYolk’s reads-list, but I also don’t see it (i.e., the list’s content) as a reason to scumread him. I don’t know EggYolk, but -from what I have seen thus far- I know he isn’t the type of player who will give paragraphs of non-empty arguments to elaborate each and every of his reads –and on D1 on top of that. No offense to the egg, but he doesn’t seem like that kinda guy.
And therefore I also don’t see any reason to scumread him, because the level of content he is outputting falls within my range of expectation that I have for any player (incl. myself). If I was asked to make my own reads-list, then I probably wouldn’t be able to outperform EggYolk’s list. So the fact that the egg was proactive enough to give it without anyone asking him to make one is rather towny.
Okay i could be a little harsh for a day 1 to be fair
1 Like
What were the most baseless reads on that list iyo? What were the ones that felt the most towny?
Townread:
ACE
EggYolk
Wazza
Freezin
Chomps
Snow
Townlean:
N/A
Mild town feeling:
Zone
Achromatic
Jarek
PoE:
Gummy
Rue
ACE - started off with posts in response to me that I felt were over the top in a towny manner, her reaction to my gummy townread. Her reaction to Wazza and the manner with which she defended herself to that screams pure / towny to me
EggYolk - his emotional reaction to what I said screams pure / towny to me. I don’t think a wolf reacts like that towards a villager.
Wazza - their reaction to ACE screams town to me. I think a wolf would be more patient and guilty of being wolf, so parsing “shitlist” as “shotlist / list of suspects” imo would have been more probable. I also think that they sincerely believe in their imo very wrong interpretation of what I said re: where to allocate our effort
Freezin - townmaxxing, i just played versus wolf him where he skated by and relied on vibing and posting good tonally to end game. He managed to survive for a very long without making substantive reads, whereas he is doing here now. It feels extra more sincere because he did it as an adaptation / reaction to me doing it, so it wasn’t even his premediated idea. It feels natural / sincere to me
Chomps - i think him aggressively hurling himself like that at me is towny. He admitted he was purposefully reaction testing me by disregarding what I’m saying and accusing me of being mafia in a bad faith manner because he believes that wolf me would fold under pressure. I also believe wolf me would fold under unreasonable pressure. So that seems sincere, and if he was wolf, sacrificing his position like that to shade me seems positionally suicidal
Snow - im gonna reach a bit because i think town snow is prone to getting mischopped so it feels adequate for me to boost it a little. I think them voting me in the manner they did, without much of explanation, and making me top wagon, is indicative of them lacking TMI. I dont think wolf snow is brave enough to do this. I wasnt consensus wolfread, and ive seem town snow be brave enough to make anti consensus pushes, and ive seen wolf snow fold like a wet noodle. They also questioned gummy in a post after which i liked
Zone - i like Zone for his initial displayed reaction towards his role
Achro - i like Achro because i made a guess / gamble that he would have a much more silly / goofy approach to the game if he was mafia. He was also tired as mafia in FAM6, so id guess he would be tired of randing wolf back to back here. Maybe randing town here is a breath of fresh air for him
Jarek - vibes; gut. Explaining himself transparently, and Achro townread him
Im not married to these bottom 3 reads, i could be wrong here. These are mild townleans
Rue - gut + i didnt reach a townread on her while reading earlier, also accounting for the fact that she was one of the substantial posters
Gummy - gut + there was a miniscule thing about freezin and chomps, it doesn’t really matter to me anymore, just for transparency
My wagon is compromised entirely of people that I have in my towncore. Isn’t that a thing!
I suppose it’s not that surprising wolves aren’t voting me. I think scumreading my posts is puzzling, but hey, it happens.
3 Likes