alright here’s the Altina posts that pinged me the most and made me think they’re self-conscious about the words they’re putting out and overthinking them
This post was in regards to my “list” thing I kept doing earlier in the day, I don’t know why they were so hung up on it for no reason but they weren’t the worst one out of this interaction.
Awkward post thinking about their own posting, at first I felt this post was pretty good by it’s standard self, but looking around the post just feels weird and especially misplaced, they weren’t even really being suspected and it’s day 1, why be worrying about being townread (this eventually develops rapidly into a wagon that fades away quite quickly)
Then it was this post, from what I was aware of, Altina was pushing Meme for a good portion of the day and was seemingly overconfident in the read, the development on it is misjudged but this post feels a bit more like “Well, just in case Meme does flip Town I at least had some doubts about it”, I don’t know how to describe it properly, but I feel a town reacts in a different way with their cautiousness about someone elses slot, especially given it’s the first day.
I can’t say how much I know how Wisp plays, but from what I recall they’re a good player? So I’m unsure, but this is what I gathered from this.
Finally we have this post, the one that mostly just pinged me to vote it, this in my eyes is the worst post of the bunch because it feels like a complete lapse in judgement that I don’t see someone making, I can’t read Wisp’s mind, but from my perspective their jump to “Why would someone else out Snowe’s ability” is like completely unfounded and feels more like someone trying to get a derpclear in the case the ability that revealed Snowe’s flips and is a scum ability. It feels like a forced reaction, and one that honestly didn’t need to be made?
Granted this could all fall apart instantly if o.kazo is actually claiming the ability, but I’d rather they not specify because if they’re town, claiming here just harms all of us.
You can have a townclear for this post though I know you are capable of these as a wolf too - I like the vibe of this post, and I like where your thinking is at with it.
That’s kind of a lame thing to end off of the tail end of a wallpost but I’ve got nothing to say that isn’t “I agree with you!” and I don’t feel like being a yes-man. The more people point out things about that slot the more I vibe with voting them. We’ll see.
I can buy this, last night I was questioning why he picked RVS posts to read into as opposed to any other post, but thinking it through a bit more this morning, reading every post from the start and then picking out the ones you want to talk about if they’re early makes sense.
Can you give me some more context with the N0 green check in that game? It’s still a little weird to me that you immediately believed the N0 red check with Frostwolf, because 1) you know it’s a bastard game and 2) N0 red checks are god awful game design if they’re real (yay, you randed wolf. Someone caught you immediately because their role said so on Day 1 and you didn’t get to play)
How did he play as a wolf in FAM5?
I still want to see Memeking figure out who the wolves are but I actually like his defense towards me.
I have very little context with regards to your meta, but catbae says you generally always play like this and get wagoned. I just want some basic stuff from you. Who do you think is town? Who do you think is a wolf?
Maybe my instinctual gut was correct at first glance with regards to his AtE posts, don’t think I’m interested in voting him today.
Not really sure who the wolves are right now; I don’t think the accuracy of my readslist is very good.
I guess I can plop my vote on the Ash wagon since May mentioned the time he wallposted he was a wolf + he doesn’t have any notable wolfreads at the moment.
Meme town told here btw he did the same in the first mash he played. (Also how he opened with that wall is extremely towny when you realize he actually struggled to wall as a wolf when he wanted to stop wall posting as his only form and defaulted there here BACK to that when he was trying to figure out how to start solving.)
I also went through Altina not super confident there but leaning town think a few of the reaction posts were towny but wouldn’t carry much weight to that outside of day 1 (I wouldn’t like to day one her)
Also don’t think litten has been towny but would’n’t go there d1
i appreciate ur thoughts, but in all honesty, even in a bastard game, I expect town are way more open about mechanics then wolves are, sure its not full proof, so guess we will see?
Null-town from May to that conclusion after ISO diving at T3, after that May moved on.
May does switch around Ash and Altina, while Catbae’s reaction to my N0 fake redcheck is well noted and keeps engaging with the thread
Noted
Chomps
I recall this is before I announced my check is fake but the motive for that vote is not exactly town but not wolf either. (neutral alignment foreshadowing?) He’s mostly reactionary in most of the game, but by present day he become more decisive
Interestingly one of the first to vote Altina without context.
Couple of hundred posts later rejoined Altina wagon Altina (4): pandora, T3RMINATOR, Wazza, Chomps
/s I also dont believe he actually believed that
(But really anyone can see that)
Catbae starts following his gut about Jarek and likely understood what I am doing with the fake redcheck going on.
Catbae knows I am trying to find angle from my bait on T3, it’s not because he believes the redcheck is fake, but that I do make useful function out of it.
(Alarmingly, Memekingpizza has not responded back to this message)
Yeah no nonsense on this person. This is good on Catbae. This also makes him unlikely to be partnered with Jarek and dont think this is wolf/wolf
(I will add Jarek in the red text pile)
Catbae being aggressive over Jarek believing the redcheck and greencheck (But that’s not what shielding bascially means T3 is greenchecked)
Engaging with the thread (and has shared conseneus with May) and keeping the wagon options open
Hippo
early mech talk is NAI, lets move on…
/s
Knowing I am baiting without telling he knows I am baiting (fr)
Pandora’s vote comes after Kelsier and mine, not biased because of the fake redcheck
I think Pandora as slanking still has consistent posts and should engage more to the thread, for now she gets a pass
Cattail (NPC)
Indifferent, I dont know why I put him in T3 list anymore, but they are awfully fillery and if it wasn’t being NPC they would be in red list for that reason.
ya my problem is their iso is fine? not great, not bad, but they are also very stiff this game for some odd reason which is not something i saw in either wolf or town games I was linked by Litten and Tutuu?
Trying to think if Wazza genuinely believes this since that’s potentially a shortcut for reading their alignment.
wolf!Wazza is more thread control-y and plays more conventionally right? Rather than like, latching onto this Wisp wolfread and believes that they potentially found something?
