I’m gonna file this as mafia doing chicanery until further notice.
I’m going to rest for a little.
VOTE: Cattail 5.0
VOTE: Cattail_5.0
There is… a lot of evidence that would imply this is a no-mafia game…
1 Like
But I could be apopheniaing. Let me compile it and we can judge
I’m ngl I had a thought like this but who approves a mafia game with no mafia
just seems a bit against the point and boring ngl
2 Likes
@Equinox since you’re alive and I was honestly wondering about your flip
Weren’t you in a hood? It wasn’t specified on your flip
I was talking about Cattail 5.0 the other day, they don’t seem connected to the other Cattails and hasn’t posted in a while which is… weird
| Event | Normal Explanation | Bastard Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| Meowl was said to “reveal itself as the Hero” and implied this was its ability | A different wolf had this ability and used it so meowl could reveal (which would cause meowl to be incriminated on their flip, probably) or some information was hidden from meowl’s flip | meowl’s flip as a Conspirator was fake altogether |
| Rue claimed to have used the Great Sage ability, but it didn’t show in her flip | A different wolf had this ability or it was hidden from Rue’s flip | Rue’s flip as a Conspirator was fake altogether |
| Kelsier’s ability is actively about creating the illusion of a Conspirator faction | It’s just an ability | Creates the illusion of a mafia ability |
| tutuu’s ability reveals a player as a Guest regardless of true faction | Bastard game lol | All players are Guests |
| snowe flipped as mafia but then her flip changes to town | Wolf ability to fakeflip a villager | Bastard game ability to fakeflip a villager |
| The ability snowe flipped with creates a fake Conspirator-aligned player (and also the public replacement didn’t happen?) | Either the ability is fake and snowe was a wolf or this is meaningless and it’s just an ability | Okay I think the ability was still blocked somehow if the game bastard? |
| Chomps had the ability to ask how many mafia had died at any point, which could’ve been used to see snowe’s fakeflip maybe | Used to see fakeflips | Used to see fakeflips |
| Wazza’s ability creates a shortfuse game with all town | It’s just an ability/@Wazza had the choice to make them all town | Hint about the real game’s nature |
| Rue didn’t flip with the ability to join the game on another account after death and claims there’s no mafia | It’s another wolf role/flip was fake, and Rue thought saying “there’s no mafia” is more convincing than saying “there’s fakeflips” | Flip was fake and Rue’s real role let her revive |
| Wisdom’s ability lets everybody escape the castle and Guests win on Day 14 | It’s a dumb bastard ability | It’s there to let us win if we somehow stop the nightkills |
| The flavour is written kinda like we’re all being turned on each other for no reason, states that the game has been cancelled, the organizers will be involved with the game, that we’re all AIs playing this game in the far future, the game will repeat over and over again until we can escape | Once I did this with a game and became convinced it was players vs GM and outed myself as converted and I was wrong and everyboyd laughed at me | OK but it could be something |
1 Like
I did not have a choice.
1 Like
shrug, I know it may be stupid, but this game isn’t won by town anyway
I’m willing to throw my hat into the ring and take a chance
1 Like
Also I know it’s stupid, but when I was googling for what this number means, I just got “You are a powerful creator” and when you see this number it means you’re doing well in life.
It fits with the flavor so I didn’t think much of it 
I had this thought on day fucking 1 or 2, when I was like “literally nobody seems genuinely like a wolf, what if this is a no mafia game”, but I dismissed it entirely as dumb
I also agree that a mafia game with no mafia is stupid as hell, not the game I signed up for, a waste of everybody’s damn time, I like social deduction and I don’t like escape rooms.
A possibility is that it’s no-mafia-but-yes-cult, which would probably end up implicating O kazo?
2 Likes
I’m willing to kill into cattail 5.0 and okazo tbh
Yeah Cattail 5.0 and O kazo would be the ones to look at
If we’re wrong… two mafia are dead, I’d bet 3-4ish mafia are alive, we’re at 9v3 or 8v4. Not unwinnable but probably unlikely with the rate of nightkills?
VOTE: Lord_Archibald_Curst
just out of curiosity and for the love of the game
1 Like
If this isn’t someone’s role then I’m curious what all this loud stuff is
I’m trying to decide whether this thread is worth pursuing at all. If it is a no-mafia game, I’d be very frustrated. If I lose a yes-mafia game because I thought it was a no-mafia game, I’d be very frustrated. There’s worlds where this is never worth working