Which half of the post?
I liked both honestly. If she was wolf I think it would have been easy to hedge a townlean or a scumlean on you, but the fact she didn’t makes me feel like she actually isn’t sure and wants to be more confident before throwing out a read, which makes me think she’s genuinely trying to solve your slot.
The second half just felt sincere idk i resonate with parts of it bc im also trying to take mafia less seriously (with middling results ig). I guess this in particular is NAI but i liked it nonetheless
1 Like
As a certified rue hater, I think their direction, questions, posts, are townie, like I usually have problems with how they go about their wolf reads, and what feels like a lot of discrediting. But I’m not really seeing that here. The town reads/thoughts that I’ve seen I’ve felt genuine, and I’d imagine they be a lot more likely to make sure the PoE stays open, and ya I’m just not seeing anything I hate here
Thanks for coming to my tedtalk
1 Like
1 Like
I’m here-ish
I don’t think I agree that that post in particular is alignment indicative. I think Snowe is experienced enough in playing with me to not force a fake read too aggressively, and the latter half could come from either alignment.
I do think there’s some merit to the idea that snowe playing relaxed is town indicative - I know historically she finds playing as wolf a lot more stressful, and I don’t believe that she’s hiding that stress at all.
I’ll let you get back to work with your other reads.
Hello. Could you give me a short rundown of your reasons to not want to vote each player in the game? You don’t need more than a sentence.
Vote Count
snowe (4): Prophylaxis, Frostwolf103, tutuu, meowl
pandora (2): lilith, catbae
catbae (2): Rue, May
Hippopablompoyeetus (1): Ash
Jarek (1): Hippopablompoyeetus
Not Voting (14): Cattail_5.0, Cattail_IV, Chomps, iamagummybear, Liattac_VI, Litten, O.kazo, pandora, Relm, Ruby, snowe, Wazza, Jarek, Altina
gotta follow tutuu VOTE: Snowe
VOTE: Cattail
VOTE: Snowe
Major Reasons:
Ash - Town meta (not forcing reads, not appearing tunnelly, keeping an appropriate amount of doubt, reacted to pressure as I’m used to seeing v!Ash)
Hippo - Town meta (doesn’t sound insane, tried to fake a fucking red on me)
tutuu - Tried out playstyle changes at the start of the game then gave up on them
Gummy - Not sounding like FAM4 (in which she made reads exactly when expected rather than having doubt, when I think I played with heron Quizbowlcord and she sounded WAY more like this game)
Atlina - Uhhh villagery vibes. Seemed to react well to pressure, has a similar perspective on the game
pandora - Genuinely inquisitive (like Proph said), entered thread early when I know her to stall quite a bit as wolf
Chomps - I liked the “I have KP convert me” claim, I liked blowing up in shortfuse even though they shouldn’t have done that
Jarek - Feels pretty villagery and genuine, though I’ve known him to have fooled me before
Frostwolf - He seems outlandish, he seems audacious, he seems off-the-beaten path, these are traits I see in t!Frostwolf
Wazza - I liked their use of their ability instead of trying to distract people with a shortfuse game, like if you were wolf and had this ability you could try to take up a bunch of time and energy, also they aren’t seeming like that super concentrated 80% ABV agenda you get from them as wolf
Ruby - None of her posts ping me at all and last time I played with her as wolf she was lower-energy (note: she’s said this was for unrelated reasons so maybe this meta is bad, but also she told me about the unrelated reasons when she didn’t have to do that)
meowl - I liked the Hero reveal, felt vaguely villagery, seemed like a position a wolf wouldn’t be in, but this is weakening with time
Minor/Bad Reasons:
Prophylaxis - Good player, should kill wolves if town
catbae - Good player, should kill wolves if town
Rue - Good player, should kill wolves if town
O kazo - I kind of like the mech discussion? It’s not really a good reason
Relm - Honestly there’s not much alignment indicative here
1 Like
I have not done much yet and won’t be able to until evening
I’ve got interviews to prep for etc etc
Also will probably not be there for EoD tmrw- I will be at work in person unfortunately so will probably have to vote before then
1 Like
You don’t consider these mutually exclusive?
OK it’s slightly insane but like it tracks as something that happens in the Hippo brain. Hippo as wolf tends to make reads that are just weird and off and not believable. I can see what’s going on in his head when he thinks I’m wolf
1 Like
sorry for trying to kill you gummy they gave me a bomb
That’s fair, I just think it’s a little bit funny.
Could you go into detail on your Jarek read?
Fake red, is more likely to come from a town then a wolf, unless this is like super common for hippo as either town or a wolf, and they are trying to replicate, but still, doubtful, and not just that, proph has a small write up on hippo, that I fully agree with, on why they should be town
Also miller claim, usually just a town claim for what it’s worth
1 Like