I forgot to mention this earlier, but I skimmed the town games that gummy linked me and they did indeed constantly promise reads early in both, so my earlier suspicion on them has no weight.
3 Likes
no, it just doesn’t track with my (limited) understanding of his meta
this can be a town lean even if they scare me as a wolf, at least in a bubble, this reads pretty townie, I have no opinions on their overall iso
I hope all is well in my kingdom.
Please heed my message. Goodbye
1 Like
Well see this goes into the territory of how good I believe a player is and how I believe a player should be acting based on my arbitrary belief of their skill level so it’s really…subjective.
I’ve done the same thing i’ve flip flopped my read on people as I read their iso and posts. I don’t scumread myself for it, I don’t even expect other people to scumread me for it, because I’m kinda meh at this game.
Someone else like catbae, I believe to be good at this game so subjectively I expect a more refined read process that doesn’t involve wanting me dead to never wanting me to die ever within the process of 5 minutes.
When you put it like that yes I can see it being town - Backwater goofbrained belief that better player = magically knows everything quicker be damned
1 Like
ive been thinking and my role is actually great
if my reads are right i feel super proud of myself
if my reads are wrong then i get wolfread and get mechanical benefit
its a win/win and i’m all here for it
i havent ever seen them as wolf, only townie so i actually dont have a reference point like you do.
do you think they are playing the same as theiir wolf game then? or town here?
but also ur problem was letting them live to w/e was lylo may it be F9 or something smaller, because if Gira is that bad or not dead, there is pretty high chance they are just a wolf.
though this is probably unfair given that “Path of Radiance exists”
Apparently catbae has been super town to everyone else and I must have missed something to see that myself anyway so I’m clearly barking up the wrong tree by trying to read into that anyway.
Snap reads based on vibes about how a person acts in the moment still exist, which is what that one on catbae was.
you realize that i was catching up on the thread and reacting in real time, right
This is a very good game I’m glad I didn’t miss it
1 Like
this is a towny sort of self-reflection that i think comes from introspection and self-discovery that is really really hard to fake as a wolf
this read is fully hinged on the idea that jarek hasn’t said anything like this before consciously but given that premise, i do think this whole post is very towny
i think people are definitely not as confident as I am on saying Catbae is town
So like you’re describing exactly what I do except instead of just saying your thoughts in your head and not posting you actually posted them
1 Like
ya I could see it
1 Like
Oh yeah I see a lot of posts about catbae what about proph though?
i have no idea
i think he feels different to the last game i played with him as mafia, but i wouldn’t get the game on this read
i’ve lived past night 1 as town with you in multiple games lmao, even earlier this year i made day 2 (although that was probably because mafia misplayed)
i do think that he tries to control the game as town though
maybe i’m bad and wrong but i feel like Altina’s read of catbae is pretty poorly reasoned and feels like TMI
1 Like