Project Moon UPick - Night 2 (13/17)

Forum Games Ongoing
, ,
#1021

for Pandora, since I was asked about her specifically, I see a decent amount of trying to get others to give reads without actually giving very much herself. Claiming to have caused punishing bird to breach might be important at some point but is currently NAI. Slight wolflean.

Chomps is currently a player that socially reads pretty bad to me, but their interactions with the abnormalities (at least claimed interactions) seem far more reckless than I would expect from a mafia member. It’s possible that the mafia have more info than town on them, of course, but since that’s just baseless speculation I give them a begrudging townlean.

I dislike the actual takes of Gocj, I’m not a fan of how quickly they jumped on using such incredibly specific mech spec for reads, but it does read fairly town, I think a mafia would have tried something more substantial. Townlean.

Various slight leans without much reasoning behind them
Town: Leafia, Hazard, Litten
Mafia: Vi, Zoe, Zone

#1022

@snickerzVi I would love to hear some takes from you specifically.

#1023

your mental pandora model needs an update im always shy with reads because my headmates have conflicting reads and it gets us killed badly. this is self meta so it’s not as useful but it’s KNOWN self meta and theres no way lying about it benefits me

#1024

this goes back to my NLM days also. if you look. i basically never made readlists on tiermaker for the same reason

#1025

Likely true, and the read is slight enough I likely wouldn’t have bothered making it if not asked about you specifically, but I’m not about to give a neutral read on a player I’ve been asked about.

#1026

sure. i currently think of Litten and Chomps as likely to be good:

Litten is not only speaking a lot, but its posts have a lot of actual thought and meaning behind them in a way that looks pretty town-like to me

Chomps I agree with you on that the vibes aren’t particularly good but mechanically they’ve helped town and have done a lot that Mafia would be cautious on. Also tracks that they’re not afraid to do these things based on the very early claim of having a not-very-strong role

Zoe was the first player I commented on here:

and i’m still not a fan of her after her response to others suspecting her on reasons similar to mine

if there’s anything more you want my opinions on in specific i can give you that but that’s most of the Not Just Vibes ideas i have about people

1 Like
#1027

I’m thinking palsonny wolf

#1028

Hi. Please read this:

#1029

im kinda agreeing but their recent posts arent bad and id hesitate to d1 a newbie

@Palsonny @snickerzVi can you explain your current abno votes or link me to your explanations of them?

#1030

my personal reasoning for choosing The Road Home is that it’s the only abnormality that hasn’t shown any effects yet, and is a low enough threat level for me to think it can have an immediate effect. Funeral for Dead Butterflies would likely be my second choice if I had a second vote, since it both doesn’t have any immediately intuitive effects, and has already breached once, but it’s been suppressed, and it’s hard to know how soon it will be a problem again.

#1031

moth, orchestra, plague doctor ?

#1032

inclusive of both “hasn’t shown any effects yet, and is a low enough threat level for me to think it can have an immediate effect”

#1033

again, plague doctor?

#1034

Ardor Blossom Moth isn’t in Lobotomy Corp which is the only PM game i’ve played, and that plus “the embers quietly spread”, “ignition is reached”, “the flames are further stoked” makes me worried about some Arsonist type nonsense

#1035

in that I don’t know much about it

#1036

Plague Doctor is Aleph in sheep’s clothing. It will be a problem, but it’s not a day 1 problem.

2 Likes
#1037

alright fair enough

#1038

i think i already might have asked you this but how much mafia experience do you have?

#1039

like 2 years of casual discord mafia, plus another decent amount of longform discord botc. I tend to play more in very mechanically complex games, which is both part of why I’m Like This and also means I haven’t actually played very many games in total.

#1040

is there a reason all your answers to questions feel so safe