By just hearing of the conditions i can already think of a million ways i can do confirmation plays via by mech towards other players
Because it takes so long. I have yet to even accumulate a single doctor charge by my math.
I don’t believe in the hosts giving a player an ability that does practically nothing point wise
Do you really expect my ability to be confirming somebody in 1 night???
1 cost is all you need to potentially hard clear a person per day
A doctor isn’t worth ten nights
It’s like 2 nights, and can be infinite if I really want it
If you know this ability I have, isn’t it possible someone else does?
I don’t know the cost I have?
It is
the points*
Ok I actually need to drive home now
You dont necessarily have to know the cost to infer the amount by if youre able to use an ability or not, yet i see no play no incentive to try and use the ability other than wait
I dont think we’ll arrive somewhere with this argument but at least i pointed the fallacy inside your mech
Like there’s an extremely easy way to accumulate a ton of points but like if I do that I’m ignoring the whole other investigative part of it. Also gocj you don’t even know how much points each penalty applies(which like again only the highest applies). I can get a lot of knowledge and probably figure what the conditionals panned out to and confirm people but like, it takes a while and you can’t expect my role to just output instant confirmation in a single night, also how do you even know I haven’t tried setuping a confirmation method? Like yeah I can confirm a player that was voted as good but the points stack, so I know one of the two is good or both, but to differentiate I need to apply more penalties which in that time more things happened so my information only becomes more chaotic as the game happens.
yeah alright Litten is just like
town
100%
I guess I can choose not to gain stuff but like the threshold is still decently high meaning I need to ensure somebody is at an exact amount to check which is hard to guarantee
you’re town 95%
im still a little pressed that apparently our best investigative both a) did not know what abilities they were using on their target and b) was macho and had the mafia informed of their existence
4 Likes
carroty is most likely town here im willing to defend them here