I’m pretty sure they are town, but they might be mistakened and not lying on purpose.

I am So confused
If the gossip indeed procd from 1-8 then I’m fine with killing in 1-8 but if it didn’t then I think the artist is fake and we should go after the actual demon.
Next game can I have information always for free 
who even claimed artist? i can tell there’s 0% chance ur willing to talk about it. i guess im talking to myself. ive received no artist claims. why don’t we just kill them for the sin of lying?
See the problem is if they are lying I don’t think they are the demon either.
very well. but if they are a minion their motivation for lying is to clear the demon, who would be sitting outside 1-8
Yeah exactly
My grimoire makes perfect sense from my perspective, I think it’s fair to say I have more information than atlas because my grimoire makes sense, not sure what atlas grimoire is cooking though.
@tutuu
You have all the claims from most people I presume. What minion do you think otter was?
You know otter claimed pixie I presume. They can’t be Hui Jing if a pixie is actually in play as that doesn’t make sense. So if they are evil, it’s a different minion. And you know a liar then.
i have no claims from bionic, artemis, and someone. no claims from jarek too technically but he is obvious about his claim
i dont really know how to differentiate between minions. not huli jing because she would have a lot of fake claims
That’s incorrect, you gave the grimoire to luka which included artemis role
i shared my claims and my reads on people to him. maybe i shared him my read on artemis. me and her never whispered though. let me check
that’s weird he stated he got the grim from you
i told him i have zero info about her role. and i didnt have any. only later i started theorizing
i didnt give him a grim. im not using a grim. im writing my notes in a .txt file. he made his own grim. asked me if there is a template to use for this script. i told him i have no idea
Something to note is luka was like “what is x” and all my answers were “you have the grim”
no I whispered artemis on my own
Ah that makes sense