The beatings will continue until townplay improves - Night 1 - 10/11

[Daeron]

fwiw I have a bad feeling about soweli with little logical reasoning to actually substantiate that

[iamagummybear]

@Io-1

If it was a reaction fish, I would’ve expected Gummy to have asked me why I disagreed and had more of a conversation about it rather than what actually happened:

i voted her bc i really did think she was a wolf

if she had responded strongly to my accusation and started hard accusing me i would have thought she was more likely town than not

she did not do this but her post sounded really towny anyways, meta aside so i unvoted

[iamagummybear]

@Io-1

If it was a reaction fish, I would’ve expected Gummy to have asked me why I disagreed

wait why would i ask you why you disagreed when i was trying to reaction fish from leafia lol

[Daeron]

[quote=“pandora, post:312, topic:12957, full:true”]

@iamagummybear

@Io-1

Leafia’s also out of her wolf meta.
[/quote]

Okay this is hearsay but absolutely nothing is outside of Leafia’s wolf meta

that’s fair LMFAO

I may be hallucinating but I specifically remember a mash where Leafia plowed through everyone because she was “outside of her wolf meta” and I’m pretty sure I was on her team for that one so woo

[iamagummybear]

yeah that’s why i was more skeptical

idk she was posting so similar to ice cream maf and then she makes such a towny post so im confused on what to think

what do you think about her alignment

[Daeron]

@pandora

leafia towntold everyone go home

LMAO

[Daeron]

@iamagummybear

what do you think about her alignment

I’m in the range where I would be comfortable if she was in PoE but uncomfortable if she was the actual lynch

I actually agree with Leafia on their wallpost that lo-1 has been far too concerned about how they’re perceived

UNVOTE

Mmmmm

@iamagummybear

I am going to put my tinfoil hat on and say o1 and leafia could be a potential maf team

Oh wowee I was actually tinfoiling that as well that’s terrifying
I don’t think it’s real though? I think it’s just “if o-1 is mafia, leafia gets absolutely no credit because she’s a serial fucking busser”

[Daeron]

fwiw if lo-1 was voting someone who wasn’t like, an actually good vote, I would be a lot less hesitant to kill them out of the soweli/lo-1/leafia bunch that look like the PoE of today

unless someone wants to try and convince me that Zone, gummy or Chomps aren’t town (Frostwolf is not up for discussion) or that pandora is powerwolfing - but if pandora is powerwolfing we lose the game anyway because that bitch isn’t getting hung any time soon

[Daeron]

oh @ImaginaryNeon and @childe exist
uhhhh

guys plz post

[Daeron]

Town [ordered]

1. Frostwolf103 [real analysis to my gummy vote]
2. Zone_Q11 [real analysis to my gummy vote & Frost’s analysis of my gummy vote]
3. iamagummybear [has a lot better posts after SoD than before which I have already commented on]
4. Chomps [good opener, and beyond that natural posting]
5. pandora [actively generating content that I don’t think is wolfy]

Wolf [alphabetized]

• Leafia
• soweli
• Io-1

??? [requires more posting]

• ImaginaryNeon
• childe

[Zone_Q11]

@Leafia

Zone scares me a bit though. Last time he pushed on me, he was a wolf after all and whenever I’m a wolf, he’s constantly townreading me. It has me a bit worried.

You say that, when you were literally the reason I can no longer inherently trust you. Your play in Ice Cream FM (the first one) scarred me so much, that I cannot trust you based on your behavior alone.

@Io-1

Also, the votecount makes me uncomfortable and I would like to change it from the current form. I don’t feel like there’s any cohesion or trust forming.

So, I additionally want to help form a consensus. I want anyone who sees this post and reads this part to post some of their strongest townreads. The hope is that a consensus could be formed even if it’s imperfect, because I believe that without a consensus we stand much less of a chance of winning.

OTOH I’ll trust you based on a factor I mentioned in Ice Cream 2. (I may have been Mafia in that game, but I didn’t lie about what criteria I perceive as towny.)

Daeron seems okay-ish, and… that’s where my townreads stop. *looks at my own ISO* I mean, I guess Frost’s questions at me look good, but that’s neither here nor there.

[Chomps]

Leafia (1): Zone_Q11
iamagummybear (1): Frostwolf103
ImaginaryNeon (1): Chomps
lo-1 (1): Leafia
Frostwolf103 (1): pandora
soweli (1): Io-1

[Chomps]

Exercise, I want everyone to give three names they wont mind to see executed the most, I.E. their wolfreads but give me 3 gth

[Chomps]

Neon, Zone and Frost to me, but this may change if I iso frost so Frost/Childe is interchangeable

[Zone_Q11]

I think my memory issues is getting worse. I had completely forgotten about my talk with gummy until I backread my own ISO.

Inner thoughts

((So this was why I told myself to stay away from the thread for a while…))

(Yep! Nowadays we can forget a lot just by sleeping, which also resets our emotions and prejudices.)

Hm… so you say, but -now that I have backread- I am on the fence whether gummy was genuinely warning Io of how good w!Zone plays “out of concern” or just outright shading me while lying with a straight face.

((I am inclined to believe the latter. Who the heck “warns people about how good X plays as Mafia” and then says “oh no, I’m not shading you”? That’s like saying “I am inhaling and exhaling air, but I am not breathing”. It’s nonsense!))

(Welp. I tried to remedy the situation.)

GTH gummy Mafia

[Zone_Q11]

Leafia, gummy, [Neon/childe]

Now that I am checking the player list… I realize I haven’t paid much attention to soweli yet despite them having a moderate thread presence. I’ll check her out soon™.

[iamagummybear]

@Zone_Q11

“oh no, I’m not shading you”? T

when you said shading, i thought it meant shading your character bruh

idk the word shading has a lot of negative connotations that go beyond mafia play for me and it isn’t a word i use in game bc it’s heavy to me

@Zone_Q11

You say that, when you were literally the reason I can no longer inherently trust you. Your play in Ice Cream FM (the first one) scarred me so much, that I cannot trust you based on your behavior alone.

i was literally trying to repeat this argument to 1o of like not trusting you solely based on your analysis posts bc your play has been so op as mafia the last 2 games

but this is extremely counterproductive so whatever

it’s just frustrating to have everything i say in regards to you be interpreted in bad faith by you

[Frostwolf103]

@pandora

@Frostwolf103

@pandora

let’s execute all of the zeroposters

On mountainous vanilla game? No way! At least not far from the truth, its just not mafia indicative.

okay so first off why would this be wolf indicative if it’s true

@Frostwolf103

I will ignore the scale weighing Gummy wolf for Chomps/Soweli town

second off ??? like rule of 3? rule of 3 is fake it’s statisticslly 1 in 5

and then lots of pushing gummy for no reason than informative flip. and i think informative flips are fake and scummy
VOTE: frost

Your powers are weak, old gal.

[iamagummybear]

soweli, zone, leafia??? idfk

io-1 has been trying so hard and a lot of their analysis feels legit im starting to feel like they are towny again

im most confident on pandora being town and then frost i think

[Frostwolf103]

Leafia (1): Zone_Q11
iamagummybear (1): Frostwolf103
ImaginaryNeon (1): Chomps
lo-1 (1): Leafia
Frostwolf103 (1): pandora
soweli (1): Io-1

Not Voting (5): soweli, ImaginaryNeon, childe, iamagummybear, Daeron

What the hell is town doing…