last word let it haunt ;-;
reason***
Jaiden shs
This topic was automatically closed after 4 hours. New replies are no longer allowed.
Voutecount
iamagummybear (4): spookycat27, Mistyx, childe, Aleph
Jaiden (3): Zone_Q11, apennine, carbonated
carbonated (2): pandora, Jaiden
childe (2): iamagummybear, Frostwolf103
You have 5 minutes to notify me privately of any issues.
Gummy was...
Vanilla Town
Larry M. Evans
(US, 1932–2010)
You are Vanilla Town. Your only weapons are your voice and your vote.
Win condition: Defeat the Mafia.
N1 begins now and ends 2025-10-09T21:00:00Z.
1 Like
This topic was automatically opened after 23 hours.
Continuing D1:
VOTE: Jaiden
I didn’t see spooky as top town, so whoever killed him did so because:
(a) at least one of the Mafia knows he is a good player, and feared he’d eventually get them,
(b) spooky was correct about his scumreads,
and/or (c) spooky completely misread the mafia as town and they are using argument (b) to mislead town into exe’ing his scumreads.
(a) can be paired with either (b) or (c), but (b) and (c) cannot be paired with each other.
I’ll check what spooky’s reads are, but honestly it most likely won’t change my vote on Jaiden.
3 townreads, 3 townleans, 2 nulls, 1 (alive) scumread
Considering the lack of scumreads I’m inclined to think that it’s (c), but I scumread Jaiden more than those thoughts for the lack of her reads.
P#589 is nonsense as its number alone proves that 550+ posts worth of content were made, and yet she calls it “a blank page”.
spooky was the one to (re)start the wagon on gummy, and both flipped town. FWIW this saves me the paranoia of a w!spooky world.
The CFD ended in a miss, but I can’t even blame anyone who joined that wagon, as it’s difficult to townread someone (i.e., gummy) who didn’t mind dying with that attitude.
(gummy, IDC what your RL situation was; you had the time to type words → You had the time to panic, use AtE, give last minute reads. Yet instead you laugh as if you were an outed wolf. It’s a bad townplay overall.)
1 Like
So what did Spooky say?
Okay
Yeah…
Following this thought process, there’d be at least one Mafia within [Mistyx, childe, Ishmael]. Frostwolf also hopped in briefly before hopping to childe. Not sure how you’d want to categorize him.
Theoretically speaking it isn’t impossible for gummy’s wagon to be pure, and I remember for a fact that Mistyx already had gummy has one of her (few) (scum)reads, so her vote makes sense.
And spooky started the wagon presumably because childe said it had wanted to vote gummy (but presumably didn’t have the courage to restart the wagon). Point is: childe voting gummy isn’t weird either.
So, in terms of “motive to vote”, it’d be Ishmael and Frost who are lacking easy-to-see reasons to vote gummy. Ishmael didn’t have any particular read on gummy based on P#336 beyond P#353 where Ishmael said gummy is “NAI awkward”.
In P#562 Ishmael said she’d heard of worse CFD targets, so that is essentially her admitting she hopped on the wagon because she didn’t mind gummy’s death. (…which is NAI overall IMO.)
As for Frost… Eh, IDK what he’s doing. I’ll let others figure out what’s up with his actions.