i think it’s mostly because we have been mind melding thus far and he feels pretty laid back. in the wolf game i played with him there was a more concerted effort to “establish a presence”, i guess. i’m trying to take this game one day at a time and i don’t think he’s on my d1 list
2 Likes
jason / ash / youbutworse / dia
chomps / shending
hippo / ishmael
snow / willow / frost
gummy
swapped hippo and ishmael tiers, added frost to snow/willow tier, consolidated top two tiers. probably okay voting in the bottom two tiers right now depending on how things pan out. not really sure if I locktown anyone in the first tier, but I would sheep them
I don’t think most of shending’s posts would have pinged me if I didn’t see other people scumreading him. I still kinda townread chomps’s instant vt claim although perhaps if anyone could pull that off for towncred as wolf, it would be someone like chomps.
hippo/ishmael moved down for like. vibes or something. I might be really wrong here
I probably would not vote gummy d1 but hopefully she posts and gives me a reason. okay with not voting in the hippo/ishmael tier though given how many people strongly townread them (what was a town ishmael game, I didn’t see like a huge difference btwn the beatings 2 game (maybe the shending push is very different), but it could be more subtle, sorry I’m lazy)
bottom tier is probably a really bad poe bc they’re just all people who haven’t had a chance to post and become townier yet, but I guess that’s what the voting is there to encourage them to do
1 Like
oh barwe disappeared at some point when making the tier list
probably chomps/shending level. I really strongly townread the shending defense, but I kinda feel like I overweighed it
1 Like
this feels a little bit out of character but i don’t really know what to make of it. the issue is i’m not sure if i can get more from this without going into speculation of “why alexis subbed out”. it feels like an overreaction to what people’s thoughts on alex were — that he was posting towny but was not necessarily posting correctly
1 Like
i feel like the towny response to that would be “lol get a load of this guy.” and if u wolfread him off that that’s fine but why unvote at the sub. famously people do rand wolf and sub the fuck out too
1 Like
The pressuring ended and I no longed needed to vote toe slot to generate pressoure
1 Like
chomps pressured alexis out true
2 Likes
I thought chomps was playing weirdly in the last beatings and then he was d1ed and town, so I am just going to not think too hard about whether chomps is in in-character or out-of-character until d2+
i am not d1-ing chomps but if i were a neapolitan i would n1 chomps
1 Like
i do not think this makes ash towny
i kind of think “pushing everyone to make their reads publicly right away” is mostly useful for wolves to decide the optimal night kill. if person a tells person b to do something and i like what they say, this reflects positively on person b and is not indicative of person a.
1 Like
Neapolitan me i am boy
1 Like
:D
2 Likes
so yeah i do think putting jason and ash both in the top tier feels like a sneak lol
my general sense of the game rn is that it’s kinda stagnant and ever since alexis subbed out we haven’t really had a catalyst to generate meaningful interactions
i feel like my grasp on individual slots rn isn’t great so i’ll give in and open up some isos
wondering what we should do with willow. we could continue pushing her to give reads, or give her a day so she can become more readable d2 with flips and mech info. what do people think?
2 Likes
barwe (who has been towny) did rebut my tone reading of shen so that makes me feel maybe five percent better but i don’t like the slot still
1 Like
i don’t think she’s going to do that
1 Like
i’m interpreting this post as a soft defense of willow / not being a fan of that wagon anymore and looking for a new wagon to gain steam. true?
reads for now
keep in mind i townread may like all of last game. so. yeah.
town: hippo, barwe, ishmael
slightly town: ybw, chomps, jason, meow
null: snow, frost, gummy
wolf: willow, ash, shending
1 Like
not really a soft defense, but yeah i’m not really sure what continuing to wagon willow will do to advance the game. I know you’re a fan of factoring in information when deciding who to wagon, and if willow isn’t going to commit to giving d1 reads, then idk what info we gain from that
3 Likes
i’m sooo fluent in jasonese