The bad faith answer is that votes in the first 36 hours of D1 don’t matter and can be switched off of with no consequence
2 Likes
Yeah jason didn’t actually case Willow or dunk on them they just single voted them and didn’t encourage a wagon on them
1 Like
Well no because everyone except for me unvoted her once she claimed
If Ash did not CC she would have lived probably though I would have tried to rally it
2 Likes
The way I see it, Ash bluffed and Willow just froze.
Insane bluff to make when Ash was previously on the Willow is town train
1 Like
Yeah just strange, there must have been a reason they didnt claim tracker.
Ash is still BG claim though, it’s just the flavor claim didn’t come fast enough for Willow.
She didn’t think flavor claims were allowed
I think flavor claims are a bit cringe and give people who understand the flavor a massive advantage
I am used to it because all my games have fake claims with full flavor
+1 on not understanding why willow didn’t claim tracker
my tinfoil was that snow is also mafia and it would have done nothing but force willow to provide town-helping results or die while still flipping a wolf
2 Likes
of course, why would she wolfcase snow if this were true
Except for the part with VT’s, basically.
My stances wrt mechanics are that Snow should claim and Ash should also claim but censor any obvious weaknesses of the role
1 Like
AKA we assume it is every night bodyguard, he visited no one yesterday, and it also has some weird other thing he alluded to earlier
1 Like
I think this was significantly influenced by the alexis slot, I think i’m naturally a little paranoid of people who are loud and confidently push their reads
I thought alexis’s reasoning for his reads (image-conscious, archetypes) were good but i was waiting to see how he progressed to see if they were genuine pushes or like w/w distancing, and ig i never got to see that.
I think nothing youbie posted yday really made me think they were out of wolfrange so the slight townlean just kinda lingered
462 and 500
The reasons they townread me felt good and not like they were making the read with tmi, and i liked 500 a lot bc it shows they care about the motivations behind a post instead of just how it looks
I made the whole wolfcase turned towncase on them, if we trust shending’s meta on barwe i think barwe taking such a bold anti-consensus stance as their opener is a good look
…unless it’s exactly shending/barwe 
2 Likes
Yeah good reasoning
snow’s iso pings me so hard hahahaha
I don’t know whatever probably not d2 focus, I’ll write it up better in the evening
ishmael I don’t remember if I even really agree w any of the case against her besides that she hasn’t really said or done anything very towny I guess will see what the defense is
I’ve felt that ish has been stagnant today so hoping that changes
1 Like