1 Like
nya
2 Likes
thing is game state wise after the start of D1 i was willing to give you a townread because a lot of people sussed you without much evidence which is odd if you are a wolf.
but then you haven’t actually done much towny and the only game stuff I’ve seen is vote chomps (town) and push me (town). so im thinking i over thought it and maybe you are just mafia.
2 Likes
shrug. If I must ISO past games so be it. Although the one sample size I’m running of is probably a bad one
not pushing you strictly, just dislike the amount of thread control granted. Granted, you are trying. But then again, [paranoia bubbles]
2 Likes
At what point do I start suspecting people for doing less than I believe they could be
3 Likes
Hi soweli!!
1 Like
D2 Votecount
soweli (2): Hippopablompoyeetus, Leafia
carbonated (1): Chomps
Not Voting (6): Ash, pandora, Luka, soweli, Jarek, carbonated
1 Like
hi!!
2 Likes
I don’t like Leafia’s claim. (I also do generally agree with wazza’s phrasing that leafia wants to play the game too much compared to my idea of her townrange but also i’m not good at ideas of leafia’s townrange)
2 Likes
I’m not going to worry about Ash today even though that’s an unwise decision
1 Like
ok this is really funny because i was thinking that this is what you were doing w/rt Ash but 
anyhow this is also a bad point to the extent that I don’t particularly think I need to refute it?
1 Like
It is a generous interpretation of why the game is quiet
2 Likes
idk something about this jarek/hippo interaction just screams. bad. and not just because i disagree with many of the takes. going backwards:
I don’t particularly find carbon to be particularly energetic from what I recall so i’m taking jarek’s description here & “lets go get em’” is in my experience not super AI people say it sometimes, sometimes they don’t. I’m not going to touch that being ‘very casual’ to jarek
?? no. first of all. oh no we’re doomed if we live until d4 which is. F-4 assuming standard kp (which this admittedly isn’t quite sticking to so far), Ash being the far-and-away lead makes him a good target for doctors & thus a plausible doc dodge. And also it’s a very plausible progression to go from the hyperactive d1 to a de-motivated d2/d3. zzz. try again.
(this is in response to the jarek post i don’t like)
and then hippo suggests two townies (me & wazza), in particular childe for… doing childe things.
1 Like
sorry i was saying the latter point that leafia is going to be questioned ‘days later’ (again there’s not that many days. halfway rule is not a predictable factor to work around even when it is) for not dying to anti-claim that is almost certainly not boundless killpower especially when there’s a degree of plausible deniability to any not-hard claim made 20 posts into the game. that’s the exceedingly bad point.
1 Like
like sure i get game is not very active and that sucks. maybe don’t vote because “that gives us most info” because. well first of all I think people always ought to specify what sort of info. But also you’re removing a good chunk of readability on your vote here! Even if you’re a big vote-pilled vca fan “ah well hippo voted v!carbonated because it had the most info” is not readable (obviously a wolf flip looks better upon you but even if carbon is exactly rand that’s not a lot of expected info!
also wild pivot like if you take the typical info-vote principle of “voting out townies with very few posts does not advance the game” (which I’m not a big fan of but) then why go for childe here?? It doesn’t seem like you actually think childe’s that much likelier of a hit here
(wait which fangan)
1 Like
really don’t like this vote in the context of #202 from carbon being pretty decent (at least FMPOV, part of it is that she names an issue i had with your slot in being too jumpy)
1 Like
@Hippopablompoyeetus let’s talk about this 
(I’ll try to gather my own thoughts on chomps beforehand but)
I can say pretty confidently Ash wasn’t attacked last night fwiw.
1 Like
it’s really hard to gather my own thoughts on chomps especially in comparison to most recent beatings game, but I do tend to think his recent single-minded focus on carbon is a rather bad look, it… has a malicious aura to it (ftr this does mean i’m somewhat retracting my agreement with carbon on the chomps switching too much even though i still think it was a towny thought).
Like the cheap way of phrasing chomps is "he makes no effort to actively explain why carbon is mafia nor to re-evaluate carbon, as we see in thread, in particular this fallback looks bad
& i think the lack of desire to engage goes beyond beatings into my recollection of other chomps!v meta
(also not quoting for the sake of length but the “it’s a game/it’s not like i’m going out of my way to hard push you and make noise” sequence is really bad (especially when it ignores what carbon is saying which is that it feels especially bad to have a seemingly thoughtless vote being the reason you die.
I am sympathetic to chomps’s opening being towny but like. be so for real.
2 Likes
ftr I don’t like (both the assumption that everyone at EoD was town) and also Jarek’s general over-insistence on his own being town it leaves a bad taste in my mouth especially when he’s really not doing anything further to help besides complaining. Not too interested on pulling this thread more rn but wanted to tie things up for rn w/rt jarek
1 Like