100% BOTF XXX: STEWARD STRIKES BACK PART 2 - EVIL WINS

No mag is town. Mag doesnt kill themselves in the night so early

Wait is that how that actually works

Yes.

That actually fucking pisses me off. Why is that a fucking thing

1 Like

I mean evil can receive bluffs and disregard them.
On top of this evil consists of 4 players and there are only 3 bluffs to go around.
It’s possible an evil would choose to forgo a bluff to give one to another player (Guava) who then didn’t get it.
Meaning instead of 1 evil seeming to be missing a bluff, 2 instead would be.

Because the red herring has to be a good player.
Not an evil

Fortune teller should never be on a summoner script i have fucking decided. I cant even narrow the demon

1 Like

No no I’m not saying Mag is evil.
Just Mag is… wrong.

Your words were their claim doesnt add up

Exactly Hazard can’t even narrow the demon much down anymore.
So we just kill into Silviu/Lotte and go from there.
Killing them both in most worlds just makes it so we win

Their claimed world at least is what I mean.

Disregarded in a Summoner game, there’s also not much point in withholding bluffs from your first evil partner instead of talking to them, and them ejecting them into a double claim because eh, they’re covered, and then fail to message the second at all instead of returning to the first. Realistically it would be first-come-first-served, “here are the bluffs, which one do you want to claim, alright one of us tell [X] to claim the other thing”.

It’s not a good defence.

Ok so now zug can be demon in a fucking summoner game so my 1v1 plan doesnt work

I do hate to say it but we have no reason to know it’s Summoner over the other minions.
It’s possible that this is just a regular demon game.

I beg to differ.
I wrote the case setting personal feelings aside, hence why I over relied on whisper tracing and external tangible behaviour to explain rather than simpleminded intuition, so it shouldn’t just be “wrong”, it should be factually and empirically incorrect if so. So tear it down piece by piece, if you’re so inclined. I wish you the greatest chance of success.

Yes we do.
Hazard greenchecked you N1 and nobody else can have starting bluffs, which is corroborated by the lack of a Witch kill. If that’s false, start by picking a target and building a short case around it now, sure thing.

Witch - We had a death during the day yesterday, you’d think that if Demon is a Po then a tinker if there is one would be saved for a Po charge night.

Assassin - An extra kill to hide a no death situation such as myself exorcising or an innkeeper or a Po charge or whatnot / to make us think a gossip is true when it isn’t.

Godfather - Outsider count being off then would make sense

Literally yesterday.

You think iceT’s death was a witch?

Icet was the Tinker in a well-regarded double claim. Implausible Witch target even if you don’t really know anyones’ roles, and we had half a dozen nominations on D1.