17776th poster gets a cookie (cookie thread (Part 7)) (Part 11)

Typically a slightly nerfed Nintendo Loop classic, “colour detective”, where instead of learning “town”/“mafia” you learn like “blue”/“orange” and you don’t know which corresponds to which

3 Likes

Okay i dont like cop because i think the dayplay that it causes isnt interesting

2 Likes

i was in a game with this role once except the colors were just the given factional colors

1 Like

we n1’d lol because they were the best player in flicker

2 Likes

Once, when I was wolf, my team correctly spotted that a player was colour detective, and correctly spotted exactly the checks he had been crumbing, and correctly spotted that there was just a death of one of his checks, meaning he had a redcheck on me

…so at SoD, I claimed colour detective, with a redcheck on him.

5 Likes

I merely tolerate village idiot botc because the dayplay is more interesting but it is still a cop

1 Like

The counterclaim looked terrible!

He left the server after that one

3 Likes

Unempathetic . . .

it feels so good to look at the kill-log of my past wolf wins.

2 Likes

I also really like the push-your-luck gameplay of cop, like in my first game we were cop and got a redcheck but decided to crumb it/push it as a social read because we thought we would never get nightkilled since we were highly suspicious (we got nightkilled as we were about to get a second redcheck

3 Likes

That one was “cop, but you know there’s also a cop with reversed checks in the game, and you don’t know which one you are”, which is. OK well it’s extremely poewrful but also fairly fun

1 Like

The dayplay isn’t that interesting but I’m used to playing in places with strong “don’t reveal redchecks first thing” etiquette so shrug I don’t mind thaaat much given it can do a lot of fun things

2 Likes

it still annoys me that silviu made us plan an entire nightkill and play for an extra 24h in a mechlocked game because they wanted to sleep

2 Likes

flicker also annoys me in general but i like blaming things on silviu when i can

3 Likes

Silviu asked me whether they should call it, and I said “I’m busy RN… don’t call it immediately it’ll make me SAD” and so it’s my fault

1 Like

That’s funny. Flicker annoys me too

Simply dont sleep (I was sleeping when players hammered once and woke up to people thinking i went awol and someone else had to take over the game)

1 Like

why would silviu listen to you.

3 Likes

i keep trying to claim night one hypothetical red checks and without fail people will ask me to confirm if ti is real

IDK like I think vanilla “cop” isn’t the most interesting role in the world but even mild variants create fun situations precisely because it is so powerful

1 Like