18981st poster gets a cookie (cookie thread (Part 7)) (Part 10)

Rapiers can slash

Katanas can stab

You can use the butt of the spear as a staff. Staffs are very effective weapons, even wooden ones

1 Like

The only bad thing about swords with full hand protection is that their bulky shape makes them inconvenient to carry, and inconvenient to transport. You cant stack them on top of each other like swords that only have a cross guard. And front line soldiers spent most of their time not fighting than fighting, which means utility and convenience was very important

1 Like

The rapier is very OP because its basically a short metal spear

2 Likes

Weapons are exceptionally lighht

Maces are exceptionally light

Full plate armor is exceptionally light. It restricts mobility because of the chunks of steel not being bendable not because its heavy. You can run and jump and do cart wheels in full plate armor

1 Like

Axes and maces require strength to land powerful blows. There is very little strength needed in sword fighting. Using bows requires more strength than sword fighting

1 Like

If a video game were to be realistic, the full plate knight with a sword would be the DEX character, and the lightly armored archer would be the STR character

2 Likes

Nothing new learned regarding the first half since that’s just stuff regarding the southern expedition; I already know what happened thanks to POV3, POV5, and POV9. What is new, is uh… *clicks tongue* there appears to be a body found with a decapitated head. Male, blonde, relatively tall. A possible match to Lucien, who had been MIA since the very end of E6.

The body was also stripped of his clothing, meaning that if it was Lucien, then there might be someone walking in the fort with armor of the provincial guard. …on one hand I pray this news wouldn’t arrive late to Solomon, but on the other hand I fear this might increase his stress.

Other than that, despite being denied of a pay raise by Mr. Thorn, it appears that members of the high council from the capitol has given all guards a one-time bonus of 30 pieces. (Essentially a week’s worth of wage at once, I think. Daily wage IIRC is around 6~8 pieces, and meals cost around 3 pieces a day.)

Now I don’t know what other guards will think about it, but I am more nervous than ever. On surface level, it seems like a generous boon, but my mindset follows that of Solomon’s; whenever some reward is given, it is often a means to raise morale for the arduous future that comes soon.

1 Like

Flails are a fictional weapon

2 Likes

unfortunate I’m a fan of flails

4 Likes

I mean okay usually the full STR melee guy isnt using a light sword in a video game they’re using a gigantic weapon

3 Likes

I guess using dark souls as an example because its the first thing that comes to mind

Swords like a rapier are pure DEX, but stuff like a longsword actually needs both STR and DEX. If the sword is pure STR, it’s probably a comically oversized greatsword

1 Like

First 10 minutes after cards up: Woke up w. Stiorra next to her on her bed. Slept while studying books; comparing notes. Had to sneak Stiorra out of the coven building.

…oh also, stream mic was muted. (Chat had to go to other characters’ streams to relay the issue.) The problem was fixed in a jiffy, but now chat would have to watch multiple perspectives to know the details of the conversation. (Though, that’s probably unnecessary, as context clues were given, and other characters’ voices were unmuted.)

Actually the best melee weapon(s) is two longswords, one in each hand

2 Likes

3 Likes

so true bestie

2 Likes

“if a video game were to be realistic”

Skinny people can fight with swords just as well as muscular. You dont rely on your strength to land blows with a sword (irl)

1 Like

The zweihander is the biggest comically oversized sword that was used irl and it weighs around 4.5 pounds

2 Likes

historically speaking the most important aspects of warfare in terms of the individual are endurance and finesse as opposed to raw strength. above a certain threshold you get vastly diminishing returns

5 Likes

this matches with the macro scale of conflict in which supply lines and sustainability matter far more in terms of any kind of pitched battle than individual tactics or strategy

3 Likes

Yes and archers and especially english longbowmen required a crazy amount of strength to pull the bow

1 Like