BotF I.I - Hand of Darkness - Good wins

[Sharklifter]

I think its a good idea

[Zone_Q11]

@Wazza

who’s nominated

Read my posts please:

@Zone_Q11

On a side note: Voting Phase starts in roughly 10 minutes.

The nominees for execution are:

1. Wazza
2. Whysper
3. Shark
4. Intensify
5. Arctic
6. Storyteller

Then there is also the nomination of GGhana’s exile.

To those who are new to the game:
You have to vote either Pardon or Execute for all execution nominees. As for GGhana, they get a separate type of nomination where you can either vote Exile or Stay(?).
The difference between these two is that some votes for the execution nominees will be locked the moment you submit your vote, while exile votes can be changed at any time before the day ends (IIRC).

@Zone_Q11

@EggYolk

Oops sorry, little hard to follow noms in this format.

No problem. That’s what I am here for:

Red = Locked votes (Cannot be changed once put)
Green / No color = Not locked votes

@Kiiruma

In DMs to me, we 3f3’d.

CRich said ‘King, Choirboy, Fisherman’
I said ‘I am King and I have a claim of Fisherman already, so don’t f about with me. Are you my choirboy?’
And they said ‘I am choirboy’

Odd… He said he had a reason to trust Shark’s–
Never mind. I see what’s going on.
The only thing I am confused about right now would be the third Choirboy claim.

[Intensify]

@Zone_Q11

@Host_Account_3

Politician : If you were the player most responsible for your team losing; you change alignments and win, even if dead.

It says: “You change alignments and win”
Change alignment to what? Evil?

@Host_Account_3

Atheist : The Storyteller can break any rules, and if executed; Good wins, even if you are dead. [All players are Townsfolk or Outsiders]

It doesn’t say that the Storyteller is evil if there is an Atheist in play though?

Politician wins with ST if ST wins in an Atheist game

[Kiiruma]

/Accept

[Zone_Q11]

@Sharklifter

Just flowergirl test me for it?

For that to happen you would need to not die and not vote today.
Do you think you can do that?

[EggYolk]

You can also say that in a sense that if Good loses, Evil wins, and if the Politician is the most responsible for making Good lose, they turn Evil and win(since good lost).

It’s not officially confirmed, but IMO good to ask @Host_Account_3 how they rule Politician if atheist is in play. If I was STing this I’ll deffinetly rule it as “If the politician is the most responsible player for making everyone believe that there is no atheist in play, the win”.

[Zone_Q11]

Wow. That sucks.
Welp. I am still not believing Arctic’s claim, so I will vote on Whysper instead.

/execute Whysper
/exile GGhana
/pardon the rest

@Host_Account_3

[Sharklifter]

Oh wait shit, yeah your right, but then who would we go for? Because logically I’m very confused and I think I’ll die tonight either way to make it seem like I’m Fang Gu

[Atlas]

Shark, if your telling the truth about your Minions

Your not the demon

[Intensify]

@EggYolk

You can also say that in a sense that if Good loses, Evil wins, and if the Politician is the most responsible for making Good lose, they turn Evil and win(since good lost).

It’s not officially confirmed, but IMO good to ask @TheStoryteller how they rule Politician if atheist is in play. If I was STing this I’ll deffinetly rule it as “If the politician is the most responsible player for making everyone believe that there is no atheist in play, the win”.

It’s confirmed that Politician wins with Storyteller.

@Zone_Q11

Wow. That sucks.
Welp. I am still not believing Arctic’s claim, so I will vote on Whysper instead.

/execute Whysper
/exile GGhana
/pardon the rest

@TheStoryteller

why aren’t you executing the literal openwolf rn

[Sharklifter]

@Intensify

why aren’t you executing the literal openwolf rn

what is an openwolf

[Atlas]

When someone is openingly a wolf

[Sharklifter]

if im not the demon we can flowergirl test me to make sure if its really needed

[Sharklifter]

so evil?

[Atlas]

Its important you don’t think your demon first

[Atlas]

When someone’s evil and town knows they’re evil

[Intensify]

A person who is openclaiming evil… in which case you cause you’re claiming to be the Lunatic but we don’t know about that.

It’s pretty much best to kill you today either way

If we do figure out you’re the Lunatic (which requires figuring out SW isn’t in play but weh) then… we get some important info

[Sharklifter]

but im not evil!!! (probably)

[Sharklifter]

Either

You execute the real demon and get rid of the SW’s power immediately instead of later, its a win win
OR
You execute the Lunatic who will get proven as most likely Lunatic and we can figure out stuff from there

How can we figure out the other (potential) minions anyway?

[Zone_Q11]

@Sharklifter

Oh wait shit, yeah your right, but then who would we go for? Because logically I’m very confused and I think I’ll die tonight either way to make it seem like I’m Fang Gu

You do realize that for that to happen, you -as Fang Gu- would have to correctly kill an Outsider, right?
–also, I am going after Whysper. She talks the least, which caused her to be UTR, so she would be a good Demon candidate.

@Intensify

why aren’t you executing the literal openwolf rn

Because CRich convinced me that he can find the Demon faster than we can kill the immortal serial killer which needs to lose Roshambo to actually die.