BotF I.I - Hand of Darkness - Good wins

Forum Games Completed
,
#3001

Don’t know why people think I’m evil so much I’ve only voted to kill the storyteller I mean come on guys :slight_smile: how bad could it really be??

#3002

I don’t think I ever got that chat that I asked for :sob: and the nomination was just thrown out there so someone else with more of a good idea on who to nominate gets to nominate instead of me I mean come on you’re grasping at straws there.

#3003

You see, this post is bad, from any alignment perspective, you’ve practically put Jarek in a heavy discredited spot to a degree that even if he wins RPS, which he won’t, you’ll remove any credit he gets from that, not defending him or anything, just thought I’d like to bring that up that I dislike when people do this sort of thing

#3004

Unless you have a really good reason to believe Arctic is the Atheist, you shouldn’t be voting the Storyteller if you’re good.

#3005

I see that this thread is quiet. Time to vibe in silence.

#3006

Well truthfully there’s very little to go off of D1 but the fact he’s doubling down on a claim so hard that even me hardcore bullshitting scarlet woman for 20 minutes couldn’t shake the whole “I am definitely an atheist” thing he has going on makes me think he actually genuinely legitimately believes he is the atheist. If he wasn’t I think there’d be a slip-up by now.

Or he could just be the marionette - still evil, still thinks he’s the atheist without knowing any better

1 Like
#3007

This is the reason my vote went to the storyteller though I have changed my mind for now because yes why not wait a little bit and see what happens

#3008

In either case, Arctic is sticking their head out way too much to be the Demon.
He’s either the Atheist, an outsider or a minion.

#3009

I’m pretty deadset he’s either the marionette or the actual atheist yes

#3010

I can see that tbh.

#3011

Oh yeah. Fuck that plan. It’s too late now.
The only ones I haven’t seen vote as of the post I am quoting are:

  • Mistyx
  • Kiiruma
  • Atlas
  • GGhana
#3012

If you all could make your own individual VC, that would be even greater.

Screenshot_20211209-104024_Sheets
Screenshot_20211209-104024_Sheets970×875 208 KB

#3013

Well there’s a hard lift on Whysper. I feel a little uneasy about that.
That and Wazza voting is throwing off my confidence of Whysper being in PoE, though I should remember that she’s good enough to double bluff.

#3014

From what I see:

  • Only Shark is about to die
  • GGhana needs 3 more exile votes to get exiled
#3015

There is one problem with us executing Whysper on D1, and that problem is called Shark. We all need to collectively agree on a couple of things:

  • There is a non-zero possibility that Shark is actually Fang Gu.
    • In the event that Shark is Lunatic, we might have lost time, but at least the source of chaos is out of the game.
    • However, this most likely means that we need to start hunting down the Minions in the event they are the Scarlet Witch.
  • Wazza and Arctic are Minions. This is not an Atheist game.
    • Wazza is hard to kill since she needs to lose Roshambo before she can die.
  • We still need to confirm the roles of Leafia and Whysper. (Actually, now that I think about it, isn’t Leafia confirmed Noble?)
#3016

Wait a minute.
If Leafia is Noble, and Shark’s Minions consist of [Wazza, Arc, Leafia, Whysper], then -assuming Shark is legit Demon- it implies Leafia is faking her results of [Shark, Intensify, Eli].

…I mean, it’s not impossible, but it really sounds improbable. The only way I can see this happen is if Leafia had whispered Shark before claiming her Noble results.

1 Like
#3017

Yes I can see that the execute Shark wagon is quite a bit more than execute Whysper.
Which feels like the wrong choice, yet if it’s a Fang Gu game and they are the Lunatic then we take the possibly they’re the Demon off the table the following night.
If the Storyteller is nearly tied or is tied with Shark, I’ll change my vote to execute Shark to break any ties.

#3018

Okay, no. Leafia is not a neighbor to anyone evil -assuming Shark is Fang Gu- and she claimed her Noble results in her first post. Unless this is some Arctic-level FPS, it’s impossible for Shark’s Minion claims to be correct.

#3019

So there are two possibilities from where I stand:

  1. Shark is not Fang Gu, but a Lunatic.
  2. Shark is Fang Gu, got confused as ****, claims Fang Gu, and upon realizing he openwolfed, he lied about his Minion claims.

…I’ll take Option 1. Back to Whysper.

/pardon Wazza
/pardon Shark
/execute Whysper

@Host_Account_3

#3020

If Shark is Fang Gu, then there’s a good chance that one of the minions is a Scarlet Woman.
As I doubt the Storyteller/s would like to end the game D1 with the Demon dead if possible.