For whysper to be the demon here Richard needs to be evil
Otherwise Whysper is a townsfolk.
My nomination on Whysper D1 would point towards the two of us being unaligned.
Thiis figures because:
If Egg is drunk, giving them a 1 consistently is hardly making them drunk at that point, though it makes the puzzle harder I guess…?
If this is true then that means that the 1 was false and the true info is clearly not a 0, so it’s a 2.
That means that the puzzlemaster guessed correctly and it’s whysper clap clap.
Or there’s a world where it is egg and they still got true info the entire time for…some reason…
Not necessarily, either is fine with me. We do have atleast 2 exes, and Wazza who’ll be reducing worlds for us.
Elsewise, Whysper is a townsfolk and cannot be anything else assuming* the balloonist is real and is not in some way lying themselves.
Giving the Drunk empath a 0 besides the Psycho makes no sense, you can give a 1 to give them the illusion of sobriety and then malfunction them later.
And if the balloonist is fake and it’s not whysper, I can see a world where the evils are:
Arctic/Mist/Wazza - Minions
Shark - Demon
We’re at a 50/50 either way where failing the guess most likely means someone gets a fat L from a loss conversion.
Malfunctioning you later only makes sense if your neighbours ever die, and they never did
The storyteller has no way of knowing what will happen to my neighbors on N0!
So yeah it’s entirely possible.
I guess it’s a 50/50 with an educated guess on Whysper here.
But Mist being real means…What exactly?
I will say it’s a cruel joke to put the Empath next to a Psychopath if you ask me.
Real balloonist probably means that Arctic is the cerenovus.
It means 3 outsiders if it was an imp game and 4 if it was a fang gu game. I think for my world to work it has to be an imp game, to maintain 3 outsiders whilst keeping the minion candidates there.
This does most likely mean Arctic is a cerenovus and the SW is Whysper who has been unable to pass due to the lycanthrope.
Does that work for everyone else?
Question: Do we think both travellers are evil? If so we need about 7 votes on Whysper to stop evils tying if we have her nailed down as the Demon.
In general, I don’t like Psycho on this script, not a nice interaction with King/Choirboy, A little trash with Imp and also immediately confirms no Legion and 90% no atheist.
My World:
Arctic - Cerenovus
Whysper - Scarlet Wamen (IMP)
Wazza - batshit crazy
Shark - Imp
OUTSIDERS:
Snitch - Richard
Atlas - PuzzleMaster (Made EGG [Empath] Drunk)
Lunatic - INTENSIFY (Believed they’re an Imp)