BotF I.I - Hand of Darkness - Good wins

No it means you’re right and we’re killing a Demon. I’m just justifying why your “answer” might have been correct and why Egg would be drunk

ST might be wanting to give misinfo later, also the Puzzlemaster is an Outsider and will more often than not hurt the good team than help.

Does it matter if storytellers keep screwing me for no reason
No

Whysper is the demon, and there’s nothing more, I believe

We’ll see after the game

The thing is the baloonist info is just wrong and doesn’t match with yours the only explanation is that the baloonist is fake or you are wrong (or fake)

Ballonist info could be right

And I can only come to the conclusion that they are the marionette because I doubt you’re fake or lying, entirely possible you are, but we’ll see

We’ll see my brain has melted and I think I overcomplicated it somewhere down the line

Whysper is the SW that got turned demon after shark died, which means
N1. Atlas - Outsider
N2. Whysper - Demon
N3. Wazza - Minion

We are dead on the money that whysper is some kind of evil, what kind is to be seen, that’s my bet.

Investigatives go last so

Yeah that works for me. I guess I over-complicated it for no reason lol

Eh, my head hurts too

For this to be accurate I would say they need to be a fang-gu though.

Ok if Mist is telling the truth about the Cerenovus, then there is no Marionette thanks to the Scarlet Woman and Psychopath also being in play.

To justify the 4 (real) outsiders

Or Arctics evil

Actually no they can be an imp so long as arctic is the minion

Yeah see my brain is rotting

at least I contributed to this thread today:)

I think we got it though