BotF XVIII: Hurdy-Gurdy Fanfare - GOOD TEAM WINS

Nope

Also @Litten you’re claiming I’m the organ grinder and I’m the one who suggested we each state what we’re claiming to have voted.

That way at least one person may know that someone is lying.


You were also arguing yesterday I was the Fang Gu. Its a bit weird you’re trying so hard to push against me

As for @guavagudetama as the gossip, your gossip ability, if correct, has to kill someone who is not protected and is not already dead - In order to allow us to solve your gossip as correct.

Personally I’d say your gossip is likely to be false. There’s no benefit for the demon to sink kills, it gives us more time.

We currently know it’s not Vortox which is a big start to info.

1 Like

/accept

Sure it’s possible the demon pinged off the innkeeper. But we don’t know there’s an innkeeper.

In the world where Guava failed to gossip correctly then that could have been a demon kill.

And either guava or the subject of guava’s gossip is evil

There is a Vortox check?

Not even sure why people think I can be the Demon when I haven’t even whispered to anyone D1. Like, information circulation is literally impossible unless I whispered to my neighbors, and even then it’s only consisting of 15 words.

That’s cool and all, but did people forget this game won’t end until Demon dies? Organ Grinder is Minion.

IDK how you came to that conclusion since I don’t whisper, but if what you say is true, then -unless my starting info is false- Demon is still within Litten/Leafia/Hazard.

…well, unless Nuto was Fang Gu now that you mentioned it.

If OG’s become FG, wouldn’t we know it once Nomination Phase starts?

Also, why the heck would FG!Nuto hop to–
*reads FG description*
Wait. If it is FG, then there ought to be 1 more Outsider. Even if Nuto is FG, then (1) my info is still correct because it’s not Vortox, and (2) he could have hopped to ā€œthe other Outsider that is not OGā€.

…speaking of which, I still dunno how you thought Guava is OG. So there’s that too.

Again. Lack of information circulation unless I whisper to my neighbors, of which you are part of.

If you wanna say that I hinted who Minions are–
Oh wait. [+1 Outsider]…
So if it is a FG, then Nuto can’t be FG if today’s nomination phase is unaffected by OG. (Which is still stupid; why would FG!Nuto ever hop?)

So anyhow, if you wanna say that I hinted who Minions are, then you’d have to start with–
Wait a minute. There is modifier that changes Demon/Minion count, so it’s always a 6v2 in this game unless it’s exactly Legion. Why the hell would I claim Noble as Demon to ā€œsignalā€ to my Minion-buddy and then proceed to never whisper D1? Like, the only world where this makes sense is if I am neighbors with them, which is why I wouldn’t even have to whisper in the first place, but again: Secret whispers only has a length of 15 words. It’d be like: ā€œHey, I’m [Demon],ā€ and then radio silence for the entirety of D1. Like, it’s not impossible, but it’s just stupid!


I feel like I have forgotten something else…
Oh, right. Legion. Not it, because I voted Guava and Litten, and then the kill is Nuto which makes no sense unless Gossip + Innskeeper, or something else that I haven’t bothered reading from the character list.

You mean Gossip killed Nuto?

For Demon or Organ Grinder?
I’m fine with dying, but the issue is that nobody seems to be Demon-hunting FMPOV.

What were you even supposedly lying about?
I already outed my info SOD1, so how the heck did you out contradicting info when you’ve had the entirety of D1 to lie about your claims?

1 Like

(Why the heck did Nuto even protect those two…) but also: How is this ā€œyouā€ lying?

Ah, so someone should have died, yes. (Unless you’re malfunctioning somehow.)

I want to ask whether Gossip kill can be the same as Demon kill, or simply ask why Demon has to kill me rather than keeping me alive because I am a LHF, but…

Well, if it’s a TD you want, then so be it.

Wait a minute. Dafuq?

Demon never kills the guy who outs info and can’t do anything else over the other guy who can stop kills.

So yeah, we’re just missing a Gossip kill, and the only way this isn’t a thing (that I can think of at the moment) is if Monke crosskills Nuto, or if Guava is lying.

Okay, yeah. I guess we’re in a thunderdome.
Which means Guava is Evil and Kiiruma/Silviu are Good. Good to know, but uh… when are we going to hunt the Demon?

If you believe Guava over me, then I guess I’ll just die today. I am not going to fight a lonely battle.

I don’t know which of you 2 I believe more. I’m just stating all worlds.
If Guava is good, the gossip is false.
If Guava is evil then your result clears me :slight_smile:

One issue: ā€œWhat is Guava?ā€

Like, ā€œif Goodā€ then Gossip, but which Evil is he?
Minion or Demon? If he’s OG, then we’re literally wasting time today no matter what.

(Also, it’d mean that whoever is Demon killed Nuto knowing that it’d reduce their own POE.)

Imo Guava is more likely to be the OG.
But we can agree to full send it to know for 100% sure.

It helps us with solving.

If good agrees then we only vote for Guava.

1 Like