BOTF XVIII: Hurdy-Gurdy Fanfare - Signups (8/19)

to clarify can they talk if I die

1 Like

yes, if you die your ability stops working

1 Like

/travel in as scapegoat then, seat 3
people are just gonna kill me if Iā€™m matreon and I want to survive a little bit

2 Likes

If thereā€™s not a lot of players Iā€™ll in as a regular player I just like the traveler powers

1 Like

Uh

Hm

Very unsure how I feel about this script

2 Likes

whatā€™s wrong with it

The Gambler and Gossip can both hardconfirm themselves, as thereā€™s no other way to explain a double death night.

Courtier + Organ Grinder :nauseated_face:

The Alchemistā€™s potential abilities areā€¦ something. The presence of an Organ Grinder might end up giving Good an Alchemist Goblin win on a silver platter. And on the other hand, Alchemist Cerenovus is kind of really weak without the grinder. Also, in 3 Minion games with an Alchemist, you HAVE to put a Widow in play, else you might end up with a no ability Alchemist which lmao

Goblinā€™s not gonna play well with 3 loud Minions

Legion I donā€™t think belongs here.

2 Likes

organ grinder + courtier = free hard-confirm
organ grinder + vortox = not fun to play around the auto-loss condition
organ grinder + legion = insanely hard to execute any legion especially with vortox requiring good players to vote

1 Like

Honestly I think the Legion would struggle even more to execute that Alchemist lmao

2 Likes

unlike tos or those games you hand pick roles tho right?

1 Like

You handpick yes

But having to avoid broken setups is something you shouldnā€™t need to do

1 Like

yeah but whats the point i you cant put half of the roles in together :wowee:
if you have to stretch really hard to make a good setup then id rather just. play a different script

oh I thought you were hosting this

1 Like

I do not know whether magnus or jarek are good hosts no offense
I can trust night knows what sheā€™s doing with regard to this

Honestly I trust them as STs

However I donā€™t like the script from a designer standpoint

3 Likes

yeah thats where im at rn
stuff like vortox/organ grinder and organ grinder/legion arenā€™t fundamentally bad at all! theyre just not for me

courtier organ grinder without any other character change is kinda bad though because its confirming
and yeah amelia has valid points about gossip and gambler being a hardconfirm on this script

image

me watching people discuss the script

4 Likes

how does town win with only legion

okay I read it and I see what you guys mean
from what I know botc or whatever hates mech confirms

1 Like

It hates mech confirms with no drawbacks, hence why Virgin is allowed to exist

2 Likes