Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

General
#20271

exactly

#20272

hmmm what’s a good Mafia Universe article i can beam into the collective unconcious

(the answer is none of them MU articles are bad iirc)

1 Like
#20273

unfortunately social reads don’t always work in botc because some town roles kinda just have to play like scum

1 Like
#20274

and cerenovus and harpy exist

1 Like
#20275

nah

#20276

I think roles that need to get nightkilled are perfectly valid if they just play really townie

#20277

:wowee:

#20278

although that does have to be in addition to fakeclaiming a strong role

#20279

okay but like mutant is in theory indistinguishable from a minion

1 Like
#20280

not really

1 Like
#20281

this is obviously not exactly true but

1 Like
#20282

in theory?

#20283

yeah but even then their intentions matter a lot, the why of what ppl are doing matters more than what they’re doing

2 Likes
#20284

I don’t think even in theory

1 Like
#20285

also yeah this basically

#20286

the mutant only has to lie mechanically

#20287

I think, while the reads game is underdeveloped, yeah sure you might be right
but if they could actually read people in a good and reasonable way?
nah

#20288

better example: a magician that’s too good at being socially good is not doing a very good job of being a magician

2 Likes
#20289

yeah fair

#20290

I would say that’s more equivalent to Jackal tho