Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

General
#28364

Mafia have the advantage of starting out hunting through 12/16 rather than 16/16 (while masons must manipulate votes and/or out to do the same) and being able to act as one rather than having the Discord of secret traitors, town have the advantage of the extra day

3 Likes
#28365

if i was a mason i would just not be found by mafia, how hard is that

4 Likes
#28366

If I was a mason, I would never see who my teammates are for their protection

2 Likes
#28367

that’s against the rules

1 Like
#28368

PLA setup was an all hydra game with a bunch of bullshit and a second vote sort of like how we lied about how elections worl in lizards

2 Likes
#28369

wtf why

#28370

If i was mason i would [redacted in case i join]

7 Likes
#28371

is it really :flushed:

1 Like
#28372

If YBW was a Mason I would’ve checked her first just to be spiteful, so I’m also confirmed good (and as a Mason for having a bad reason to townread another Mason).

2 Likes
#28373

i don’t rhink it was very good. however i do want to run a game with its themeing again

#28374

Because it’s cheating to not know things you are supposed to know and ruins the spirit of the game.

#28375

I mean I think hes memeing

#28376

That’s cheating unfortunately
Gotta play fair

3 Likes
#28377

No it’s genuinely againts the rules

1 Like
#28378

How is it cheating

#28379

I required people to confirm their rolecards in the game I cohosted with Gar for this reason.

2 Likes
#28380

wha

1 Like
#28381

Litten’s correct. It’s the reason why you’re asked to confirm receiving your rolecards most of the time.

1 Like
#28382

it’s definitely against the spirit of the game

2 Likes
#28383

I used to look at my teammates and just gaslight myself out of knowing it because it’s remarkably easy to set up walls in your memory turns out

3 Likes