Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

However this turned me insane so don’t do it

3 Likes

same reason trust tells are banned

Most hosts don’t bother. But I specifically asked Gar fo do it

1 Like

So like if I forget what team im on, its cheating?

1 Like

like imagine if you were mafia and then just didn’t know who your teammates were
literally unsolvable game if all the mafia did that

1 Like

no

but you must join mafia chat

whats the difference

1 Like

(well ok not quite but pretty close)

ooooh

1 Like

the difference is that one is enforcable

1 Like

also you can remember who your teammates are

Trust me I really am bad at that lmao

1 Like

i guess its kinda the same rationale as not letting potential subs talk in thread too

No - you just have to be informed when the game starts

The whole point of the mafia is that they’re the informed minority

5 Likes

We couldn’t call them the informed minority if we didn’t make sure they were informed, and we don’t have the budget to edit the script name

2 Likes

Imagine being on the good team trying to socially solve when nobody else in the game looked at their rolecards.

If anyone sees their alignment and then acts convincingly good, they’re demonstrating an ability rather than an ignorance.

4 Likes

real

In larger games I will go out of my way to not commit my teammates to memory but after a little while I always start remembering

4 Likes

In Stellaris I had such a perfect unpaired early interaction with Cape bceause I genuinely forgot he was a wolf

1 Like