Cookie Thread Act 3: The Cookie Strikes Back

THIS IS TRUE

the cat was harmed already it doesn’t count

roadkill is apparently the most moral way to consume meat, according to… peta.
eating dead things to honour their memory is common in a lot of cultures, i think
or it used to be

3 Likes

Philosophy Question: You’re reading the works of a notable philosopher, and you realize they are advocating for quite heavy-handed precepts that they don’t themselves follow. Should you take anything they say seriously?

1 Like

actually
that might be fair yeah

intentionally killing them to eat them is a different matter i think

depends upon culture but using everything you kill/saw dead is absolutely a way to honor the dead

if its just cause she wanted an evening snack its kinda gross
if it was for another reason its fine

1 Like

atlas if you died could I eat you

1 Like

If you loved your cat then you should bury them properly as you would any loved one. So the act is either evidence that you didn’t really love them, or an insult to their memory.

honestly they should make cannibalism and murder legal and then we have the moral high ground

It just does not bother me ?

1 Like

yeah the question was purposefully ambiguous. thats just so cheap. its a cheap method to cause debate between people who answer this

Skill issue ?

1 Like

i was about to post the next question without reading it
its nsfw atlas so ima spoil it

no
cannibalism is really bad for you, and it could destroy hardwires in your brain or make you receive traumatic memories
only if there was an extreme emergency situation that calls for it

Summary

Scenario 3: The Lovers

Robert and Mary are brother and sister. One night, while on vacation together away from home, and staying alone in a tent on a beach, they decided that it would be fun to have sex with each other, so they did. The following things about them are true. They enjoyed the sex. They knew that because of a medical condition, Mary could not get pregnant. They decided they would not have sex with each other again, and they have not, but they have never regretted the experience. In fact, they are still pleased that it happened, and consider it a special and positive event. It has also remained their secret.

a) Has anybody been harmed by the fact that Robert and Mary had sex together?

Yes
No

b) Would it bother or disgust you if you found out that a brother and sister you know personally were enjoying an on-going sexual relationship with each other?

Yes
No

what is wrong with philosophers

1 Like

no! it is empathetic to criticize them

no and yes. hm. i sense a theme

1 Like