i agree with wazza
i don’t know how much solving i’ll be able to get done rn for reasons that are not “i won’t be in the thread”; though if anyone wants to talk about specifically YBW i’d be down
The fact that an asterisk exists at all sorta necessitates the separation of logic because we’re distinguishing shades of players who shouldn’t be killed either way so I don’t think this is a super pertinent distinction, here. If there were a thunderdome between Daeron and any of the top 4 players (post v!Silviu flip), I don’t think it’d be reasonable to kill any of the first four instead — hence why I don’t think this works?
Socially speaking you might feel this way, and that’s fair, but moving people based on the likeliness of certain ventures instead of just refreshing ourselves on which slots should be green at all feels more useful than debating about how green they’d be. Or red, for that matter, since ITA3’s coming up in an hour.
if these are the only mech clears we have, that’s fine, I see nothing wrong with it, it’s a lot more than you’d expect to have at this point of the game considering all our top towns keep dying
we genuinely don’t need to bloat the pool and we really don’t want to
1 Like
But I could quite literally say the same asterisk exists for Cape? Something I feel is much more so.
I also should mention btw I have no clue who made the greencheck on Cape lmfao so I could be waffling but at the end of the day, there’s an asterisk on everyone, there’s technically no innocent child here.
You can’t say I may feel this way socially speaking when both the asterisk applies for Cape and Daeron, they both have contingencies, Daeron’s is much more social while Cape’s is much more mechanical for the asterisks. Where do you draw the line here? You can’t pick and choose.
Hero was consistent on it for what it’s worth.
Protesting the greencheck on Cape without knowing the source feels odd but sure.
Gori, a flipped villager, parity copped Cape with Spooky — another flipped villager.
oh ffs I remember this mech and it is literally just a fruit vendor
this does not help me, I’ve seen mafia fruit vendors and I’ve also seen flipped mafia roles that I’d consider to be worse than just a simple fruit vendor
1 Like
idk i like YbW’s posting in thread d1 see how paranoia comes up but
I’m not protesting the greencheck, I never have. I’m protesting your disagreement with what I believe to be with Daeron, I’m just simply using what you’re saying to make you realise that you’re doing one thing with Cape, but refusing the same with Daeron, what is the jurisdiction? Why is one considered an asterisk while the other isn’t when they both have asterisks?
Okay no I remember it now it’s just hard to remember everything in a mash sometimes zzz
1 Like
DRIVING IN A CAR RIGHT AFTER A BEER
HEY, THAT BUMP, IS SHAPED LIKE A DEER
DUI? HOW ABOUT YOU DIE?!
I’LL GO A HUNDRED MILES…AN HOUR.
1 Like
I think Cape and Daeron are just town, but I don’t get why one is considered to have a potential world where they’re not town while the other doesn’t when technically speaking, they both have potential worlds to just not be town.
Cape doesn’t get silent shot at as Mafia, that doesn’t happen, but I’ve not seen you brought this up once.
waza why are you even arguing this? daeron isnt in any scumlists as far as i am aware
songs on literally rn, peak
1 Like
I’m just gonna sheep Sylviu btw
252+ SpA Pixilate Sylveon Hyper Voice is peak
you scumread YBW? or what
Anything which could only be faked if a specific player rands a specific role, or wins a specific ability which is activated on the same player which just so happens to be checked, which isn’t certain to be in play — I think this is a broadly reasonable line to draw to stop tinfoiling a slot in a Mafia setup.
no i townread YbW but there’s been a number of people who’ve had her as wolf & she’s generally skirted the edges of PoE
two reasons
1, I want something to argue about (I’m bored and it brings thread engagement which is just always a net positive for town)
2, Because I don’t get why one is considered town with an asterisk, while the other isn’t? If we want to make a consistent list of mech, make it consistent. Making it inconsistent is just going to confuse people for literally zero reason in my opinion