FAM5 - Thread 5 - Day 4

ITA3 shotslist time??

I think that’d be best with an hour left

i’m most confident on lol being a hit; relm arguably should bee a contention for being the last ā€œdieā€ on luka’s list (& nutella has her as wolf and I think nutella is just town) but like… i think she’s towny

1 Like

I completely disagree on lol, what?

you think lol is like… significantly townier than other people???

1 Like

honestly yeah? It’s not much but I thought the fact they claimed they had a silent shot from the event way before anyone else was like incredibly townie?

crazy how little posts the thread has when Luka isn’t alive

1 Like

was this uh trustfall?

I don’t really think that’s clearing given assumedly other people would be getting silent shots from the event (& it’s probably more difficult to fakeclaim something on the spot + I kind of wouldn’t expect lol to lie about that sort of thing in general)

who do you think is better for shots

~Omitting the chances that Daeron could, as Mafia, have a role with an active manually cast second vote to inspire Ratchet to select him in the first place, because I hadn’t contemplated or argued that here; the surrounding debacle of this conversation follows the expectation that Daeron was vanillaised, and this is determined not to be a lie since it was resolved before votes closed the same day because Ratchet was killed off prematurely without apparent evil input, which you need to trace back to Daeron not trying to save or kill Ratchet whilst locking in the action either way so w!Daeron would’ve needed to just lie outright with the expectation of saying someone else had a secret spare vote which could be wrangled, and in order to dissuade this world you need to justify it in a continued string which doesn’t feasibly belong on the same shelf as a flat greencheck when it comes to merely distinguishing types of confirmation.

Playing devil’s advocate is less fun when it feels actively bad faith to just push why someone could be evil when I don’t think that, so I am going to formally resign — with that said, I think you’ve pushed a more confident outlook unto Daeron’s slot so I don’t think it was a wasted moment, like I did think a minute ago. Because you’ve forced me to alter the position to Daeron having a specific counter to feign this lie, it’s now comparable to Cape just so happening to be a Godfather. Thank you.

didnt dawroen get picked by the chronomancer role

1 Like

booooring

I’m taking a thirty minute power nap.

2 Likes

I wanted to grab the posts to show the timeline

I don’t see this coming from a wolf?

hm.

1 Like

i very much do

Wait

But lol mentioned he shot before he claimed his shot right? And seeing that his target didn’t die, he was free to claim, no?

Okay so I pose you this question, why do wolves not select someone with the Chronomancer role? It’s a net-positive to choose someone on their own side anyway from what we can see as it doesn’t seem to do anything against them? (If anything, unless I’m misreading it, it gives them immunity to alignment checks?)

Then I pose you the question, if wolves did select a member of mafia, why does Kyo lie? Why not just claim that he wasn’t vanillarised? I don’t get that.

I know you’ve backed off it, but I just wanted to pose the question

nap well

I guess?

I still think it’s townie idk

1 Like

maybe it’s not as townie as I thought it was because pandora flipped town

wonder if wolf lol just claims to shoot a fellow wolf instead if they lied about their shot?

it’s free credit with no verification?

2 Likes

hi pookies