reading comprehension devil
1 Like
melatonin
No, what compels you to vote Melatonin from 5-3?
Kiiruma, w/e
Already answered
?
It’s not hidden I claimed I had a BPV that was shot off at the start of D3 and no one counterclaimed an action on me that would open up the possibility that someone else was killed
With the info we have the only possibilities are that I holstered for no reason down 2 wolves or that I am locktown
Though I agree Leafia assuming she was the target when she’s VT and how would that even fail is a good observation
Are you going to explain why you need to re-evaluate Eve?
soweli and dia are my top townreads. im not tinfoiling them. i know im town, it is senseless for them to bus a wolf and clear me, and get “town cred”. there is a plateau in how much towncred one can have; you get diminishing returns. they were already towncore. w!soweli and/or w!dia would leverage their towncred to kill me and get away with it
eve is my third top townread. ive given up on socially reading her as its very likely a waste of time. im choosing to trust carbonated that she wouldn’t do something silly. it does seem like she was hinting that she’s desperadoing eve. eve is only a concern for f5
angry frog is my 4th top townread. he showed a decent amount of solving in our hood, whereas as wolf its a bit more hard to put that effort as it would serve only to pocket me (one person) as opposed to the whole thread. frog has been wearing his heart on his sleeve the entire game. he goes from crazy pepe silva conspiracy theories to making funny posts where its difficult to tell how much of it is a shitpost versus a serious take. he is going really in-depth and he is so utterly transparent in his thought process. he has shown a lot of derpyness in not knowing who died, who has claimed what, and being lost. i see him as a villager who is completely lost and kinda overwhelmed, but nevertheless trying to solve the puzzle and make himself findable
there is a big gap here in my reads on others
i still like leafia because she is just generally so prone to instantly truthfully claiming her role. she struggles with TMI, she is just very innocent and transparent (as either alignment). i do believe her that she has no ability, i believe that she couldn’t have resisted talking about her ability if she had any. it would be a breakthrough game from leafia here to hide an ability for so long. if she is mafia, the only explanation i have is that she is exactly Mafia Goon. that would mean she still hasn’t broken her deeply rooted behavior, so like, it would Make Sense. i still think she’s town, and i’m really not sure how likely is mafia has a second mafia goon. it feels weak. though, im not an expert on balancing. mafia having 1 investigative role is very likely, no idea what’s the other one. but if leafia is mafia she is mafia goon here. i shouldnt be lazy and i should re-read her stuff out of the chance that she been TMI’ing me that i’m town. she confidently called it out before anyone else
thinking about others now. im doing process of elimination
3 Likes
i like kiiruma the most next. him purposefully not self-pressing against a villager and risking a 50/50 rand, or even a guaranteed execution, is absolutely batshit insane. crazy play if wolf, it would really catch me off-guard. he has started solving more now which is good. ill look into his stuff
i like frostwolf next. him pushing may so confidently and so much only for him to NK her the next night seems kinda wild. he was tracked to nowhere N1 which is good. he isn’t the mafia investigative role. if he is the other mafia role he made no visiting action n1 which is still possible for a role, i wouldnt know what. he didnt carry the factional kill regardless of role. actually maybe i should have frostwolf higher than this, i just talked myself into it
leafia, kiiruma, frostwolf are all kinda close to me, their placements are interchangable, in my list
1 Like
leaves me with a pool of {jason, chomps, willow}
i still have a gut feeling willow is a wolf. her posting improved after i pushed her so hard on d2 but like. somebodys gotta be a wolf. i think she is capable of being way townier than this. i think willow and jason have a lot of w/w equity. jason has willow as top townread for reasons im skeptical about. its possible the mafia all started trampling over me on d2 due to me nearly killing willow. snow, willow, jason. willow could be some kind of a strong mafia role, like a vig. although idk why we dont have any extra mafia kills then. willow could be a mafia arsonist, actually. which is very funny because isn’t that literally willow’s character from don’t starve
anyway.
i think jason has been pushing mostly towns. i have TMI on my own alignment, he pushed melatonin hard and only got off and townread her when it was too late. he townread kiiruma and claimed we have V/V wagons, but it was already too late, it was set in stone. im suspicious that he’s abusing the fact that he has TMI so he can be the right side of history, and push towns, and only retract back at the last moment and proclaim “hmmm i changed my mind actually, this person is town” but at this point it’s too late and the person dies anyway, and he goes on to push the next villager
also im still shocked by him having willow as top townread, so there is also a world of W!Jason TMIing / pocketing V!Willow, hoping that i mischop her, and using that as ammo to chain the next misexecution on me
chomps is there he exists. i dont like that he couldn’t explain why he’s scumreading me, or any of his reads. this isn’t necessarily a damning behavior for neither chomps, nor beancat. but im townreading a lot of ppl, the bar is rising. chomps could be mafia simply by process of elimination. just because he expresses this behavior in some town games it doesn’t mean he has to be town in this game too, it’s very simple for him to abuse his town meta of not explaining reads and voting villagers to just sit back here and do the same and implicitly claim that this is what he does every game so that we should just leave him alone
2 Likes
WHY DO YOU HAVE THE SAME AVATAR AS ME
2 Likes
Sorry i promised to myself i’d stop reading upon seeing the first take i fervently disagree with
2 Likes
surprised it took you this long! 
may was an every night tracker and im a 2-shot neighborizer
Hmm. I think kiiruma!v requires a strong wolfpartner/expected town force on melatonin, this is fair. And given EoD was close without 36501 or melatonin being present, Eve.
…
Eve’s townread wasn’t really telegraphed prior.
Or it was just a gamble that played off
1 Like
Hm?
1 Like
tutuu
diafiasco
Soweli
Eve
AngryFrog
Leafia
Kiiruma
Frostwolf103
Chomps
Willow
jason.mrrown
VOTE: jason.mrrown
1 Like
The more I think about this post the more I haaaaate it lmfao and not only because I do this exact system of charting as wolf too
1 Like
its the same pink haired anime girl