Grande Idea - Endgame - Mafia wins

in wordings of the OP it says “Slight changes” i dont know if switching factions is a “Slight change”

1 Like

Oh, I missed the dropped vote.
There wasn’t a manual correction by the GMs that I can tell, though, so I think it might’ve just been a site error? Not sure what would trigger that, though.

there are mafia characters on the list that can have town abilities

2 Likes

zoe was also in the convo w/ me and willow, generally finding her posting fun as well

kinda agree with ash that I’m still neutral on both of them though

2 Likes

Thoughts on Marluna?

I am gonna state willow is a small town lean just off of vibes

1 Like

I’ve been bamboozled by the dont starve willow account again fuck

5 Likes
Pings
1 Like

LOL

Marluna (1): ElizaThePsycho
Not Voting (11): pandora, zoethepenguin, Daeron, HazardWaste, Leafia, Marluna, iamagummybear, Ash, carbonated, jason.mrrown, meow

1 Like
  1. initial read was surely, she’s just confirmed town before I found out about the mafia innocent child role
  2. then decided I should just go with the simplest explanation of “probably town barring [x y z]” rather than something super convoluted with a healthy dose of doubt
  3. then I read jason’s post about her being sus and the doubts got stronger with the “what if she really is mafia and just emphasized her role is instantly for the towncred”
  4. then I read your post about this being more in-character for town marluna rather than mafia marluna; I don’t know anything about marluna meta, so I’ll defer to you for now, so now I think I’m back to position 2 / worry about it later

she’s more townleaned than anyone else in the game at the moment but not a townread? this is entirely being carried by the claim for what it’s worth, but it’s not like much else has happened so far

1 Like

Head empty

2 Likes

I didn’t really consider her role when making the read tbh

2 Likes

it’s like a bit of a risk to lock yourself as any role instantly as mafia anyway, like marluna’s claiming a role with no actions – it could result in unintended side effects like town trying to confirm that by roleblocking/redirecting/tracking her (in the world of mafia marluna)
I mean, I guess the only action that any of those actions could mess with would be the factional if she actually has the role and isn’t making it up (which I don’t think is likely to be the case) which would be pretty bad no matter what so maybe the risk works out (??), but this is all really just hypothetical probably uselessposting

generate activity do the thing gummy

2 Likes

Hm ok
Tbh i don’t believe that strongly in the Marluna read (well not enough to vote her anyways) so I’m curious how she’ll progress

1 Like

ash feels like ash, I still don’t know how he plays as mafia, so this is probably not a bad sign. the thread reading would totally happen as either alignment
jason feels like jason gummy is existing for now everyone feels not abnormal is my current lack of reads true
usually I’d be spamming even more, but it feels really awkward to spam in the same message box

sorry for my utter lack of punctuation

This post makes me feel better about t!meow due to there being thoughts in head

2 Likes

the way you send this right after I say I have no thoughts in my head

2 Likes