Grande Idea - Endgame - Mafia wins

Forum Games Completed
,
#82

VOTE: Marluna

#83

okay so it’s def not as black/white as I thought initially wonderful thanks

1 Like
#84

being mafia innocent child with the specchat communication role sounds awful you have to gaslight the thread and specchat?

4 Likes
#85

LMAO
nah i’m sure there’s mafia medium type roles
dunno if they’d interact with spec chat but still
it’s not too different

#86

itd become tricky if there were two people doing it though

#87

town traitor and alchemist, for reference

1 Like
#88

search the thread, there aren’t

2 Likes
#89

oh damn

#90

cool!

#91

Aren’t every wolf already gaslighting both the players and the spectators?

#92

unless they were written by abbreviating spectator tbh i haven’t searched that yet

#93

100% odds

#94

well no spec chat is just being incidentally gaslit

#95

ugh it brings up every special type character when i search for spec

1 Like
#96

wait sorry can you clarify this? like if we had two spectator communication roles bc there aren’t that many to begin with? also do we know for certain that we don’t have role duplicates (besides it being a waste of a role slot)?

#97

Got to #240. Will finish the rest later, but here’s what I’ve got so far:

Confirmed Not to Be In The Game
All The Lord Ones

#82 - The Evil King Uncrowned Lord
#88 - The Pope
#89 - The Emperor
#90 - Jake, Claimant of the Nine Hells (I’m presuming that Kings are the same as Lords, and even if that’s not the case, we didn’t have the King announced at start of game)
#99 - The Feudal Lord
#142 - The Anarchist
#145 - Arthur Pendragon, King of Camelot
#146 - The Kingmaker
#149 - The Good Lord
#150 - The Uncrowned Lord
#151 - The Decadent Lord
#152 - The Not-Crowned Lord
#153 - Decadacent Lord

Not Publicly Announced

#10 - Literally Every Player on This Site
#108 - Emotion, Collector of Appeals
#177 + 178 - Anointed Presenter + Fallen Presenter
#192 - Texas Red
#194 - The Senate, as botc would have me believe
#229 - Ratification: United Nations in Hong Kong

Roles I Don't Think Are In The Game

#46 - The Admin (too swingy)
#47 - The Deepwolf (#46 with even more swing)
#78 - @ Chloe (someone would die irl over this)
#87 - 10,000 rats (day BPV in a game this small would cause riots)
#91 - Roleplayer (having a role like this is too swingy unless the GMs preranded your alignment and potentially your abilities, and if you preranded it, then, like, why have this in the game at all)
#100 - Archon, Architect of Mind (conversion in a game this small is a dangerous game)
#132 + 133 + 134 - [The Multiball ones; I’m lazy to type them all out] (if this game’s multiball, there will be riots)
#144 - The Parasite (that passive is way too swingy, and a killing Neutral is very dangerous in a game this small)
#155 - The Unbidden (even 2 players that’re meant to hunt a mafia member in a 12 player game is significant)
#179 - The Mind Flayer (too strong in this kind of a game)
#202 - Subjugation: Christopher Colombus in Hong Kong (no conversion! back to jail!)
#237 - Inception: Inception in Hong Kong (destroy the hosts with laser cannons)

Some notes:

  • Nightingale (#30 town, #31 mafia) triggers off animal onomatopoeia (Me nya-ing or Jason meow-ing or Marluna woof-ing), so if we were to shoot the Nightingale player, the kill would fail.
  • 5 (#64) can do role changes without alignment changes.
  • I may be stupid (#65) can remove a player’s vote and doesn’t seem to deactive in XeLo. Given that XeLo is also not publicly announced, be on the lookout.
  • #77 is a potential lose condition. Do not say that. At all.
  • Claim Vigilantes are fun and balanced :) (#79) might be anticlaim for this game. Avoid claiming/very blatant softing (though that’s perhaps a bit too late for Marluna).
  • Yandril, the World Sculptor (#92) can remove our Investigatives. Even if you try and circumvent the Claim Vig, don’t claim to be an Investigative.
  • In the absence of roles that make you self-vote (#148), such a great tactic (#107) means that you should not self-vote/AtE under any circumstances.
  • DuckQueen (#164) gets a really strong godfather ability if they’re the top poster today. At some point today, we should decide a person we all strongly townread and have them be our designated top poster.
1 Like
#98

i doubt there’s duplicates but it’s almost certainly not explicitly forbidden
and yes thati swhat i mean
i seriosuly doubted there would be a spec chat interaction role in the first place tbh

1 Like
#99

alchemist looks so funny I love it

#100

well the spectators don’t really matter for the purposes of winning the game though unless they’re a sub or something

#101

k im tired bye

1 Like