Grande Idea - Endgame - Mafia wins

Forum Games Completed
,
#1282

(and yes this is not standard on this site)

#1283

didnt you literally townread me

#1284

Yeah on qbcord we’re notified if our action goes through or not

#1285

poe + slight tunnel + you’re kinda inactive sorry

why did you shoot me?

I’ll give a better thought process in a few hours when I get back

#1286

wait nvm i misremembered

#1287

ill be honest it’s kinda stupid but
note how i scumread you yesterday
iirc it was mostly for the reaction to a fake scumslip but
there is no way im holstering n1 as a vig and as a person who is prone to being mislynched 24/7 so /shrug

1 Like
#1288

Im willing to BET that the way mafia roles were designed here is to rework them to let them do confirmable actions that are the same as an already existing town role in the GIM thread, to give mafia de facto fake claims. Otherwise this is just unplayable for mafia, you cant just give them unique mafia actions that no town role does, and give towns all unique town roles that only town does

4 Likes
#1289

a lot of the roles in the gi thread do have mafia counterparts
but yea i get what u mean

1 Like
#1290

If somebody claims a town role that has no mafia counterpart i personally wouldnt necessarily trust it. But it is possible that the correct answer was to trust it, i cant tell you for sure

#1291

for reference THIS is my fucking role

2 Likes
#1292

God Fucking Damnit Wazza

1 Like
#1293

It does say specifically “slight”. So maybe im wrong, what I’m suggesting i wouldnt call “slight”. I dunno

#1294

well yea but u dont
need to modify the roles to mirror a town role?
there’s already like 10 roles that do that

1 Like
#1295

hell you could even use the aforementioned Alchemist role

1 Like
#1296

Right, this is my bad for not reading them

1 Like
#1297

Im town kp. …

#1298

I like you slightly more now bc your…lack of pushing me on that made me suspicious of you

#1299

insane. I’m the reception

#1300

questions I have about this circuit/meta:

  1. 2 town vigs in 12 player setup – normal? mafia kp in a 12 player setup? typical mafia roles even?
  2. is town kp expected to misfire often / are games balanced around that assumption
  3. chances willow is a neutral? I don’t think mafia claims a shot on me like this. feels like it could be a neutral trying to get towncred after thinking they shot a mafia (source: my experience playing as neutral who shot the mafia who didn’t die)
  4. are there any neutrals with kp whose wincons are not antitown (I don’t want to read the thread again please ash I miss you)

thanks and see you in a few hours again

#1301

Neutral or mafia maybe yeah