HALF-FINISHED SETUP POOL EVENT

Game Discussion
#21

also put together the flavours. have it be wildly inconsistent.

1 Like
#22

I literally already made this joke

3 Likes
#23

i said it funnier.

2 Likes
#24

I think if you make a game thatā€™s obviously a patchwork of multiple different flavors thatā€™s kind of awesome and based

2 Likes
#25

I dont agree but thats ok

1 Like
#26

itā€™s really not. we gotta fight it out.

3 Likes
#27

The joke is a natural consequence of the OPā€™s proposal and thus doesnā€™t deserve a suggestion like itā€™s a brand-new idea. It deserves an offhanded mention in the OP so you can think about it and be amused

2 Likes
#28

iā€™m not really sure what combining entails tbh but sure

1 Like
#29

My scrapped/near-scrapped queue is:

  • Music League FM (mafia but all players also need to get a certain number of votes to win)
  • Holy Grail War (basically buddy-cop Zelda Mafia EiMM)
  • Anime Mafia Redux (the original idea for this was way too ambitious)
  • Decadence Mafia (this one is based on a fictional book/film series)
  • Danganronpa EiMM?? (Closest of all of these to actually materializing, but Iā€™ve also been having issues with every aspect of this)
5 Likes
#30

I mean it fully depends on the setups. Hades II and of the Devil each have a core idea and a few roles, but would need More Roles In Them. IDK what yours look like. I was just gonna send the setup and we figure things out from there

2 Likes
#31

Hades II (there exist Boons, which are a set of publicly-known passives some roles can get, give, affect, work with) or of the Devil (each role has a Mystery they seek to answer, if you answer your Mystery you get rewards & prizes)

4 Likes
#32

For completeness:
LobCorp = every role has 4 abilities (passive or active), starts out only knowing how many players their abilities target and when, they have to earn boxes to unlock the descriptions
Boundary of Death = insane anticlaim in which exactly one person is allowed to claim per day, subsequent claims are able to be instantly dayvigged
Super Mario 3D World = open setup but thereā€™s 2 of each role

2 Likes
#33

mine look like a lot of roles but need a core idea tbh.

MMMMfia is older & thus generally more ā€˜just a lot of rolesā€™ but also has album theming. itā€™s also rather boring imo but could arguably work with of the Devil as described

Mage council came about w/rt the MU setup competition i had some ideas and then tried to fit them in together so it is kind of more connected? Some of the roles there could probably fit into either of those i think

(For completeness PR training was me trying to convince people to play PR-heavy games not much clue what else went on)

1 Like
#34

Iā€™m kind of Nintendo Loop brained arenā€™t I. Most Nintendo Loop games tend to have a gimmick, so I always start my setups from some Idea

3 Likes
#35

I have tried this but they just donā€™t get very far in part because i donā€™t really have good gimmicks

1 Like
#36

i have a game that got canned but itā€™s just a very boring carbon-14 setup

4 Likes
#37

otD has more stuff in it, so wanna try starting from that one?

1 Like
#38

:thumbsup: in that vein iā€™ll send Mage council or whatever iā€™m calling it?

omg they got poker in 2 weeks, of the devil reference

1 Like
#39

like three years ago i half wrote a genshin impact mafia game that would have type advantages based on the elements in the game but then i developed post-gacha clarity and quit the game before spending any money

inspired artists are welcome to take this concept and run

3 Likes
#40

oh ours is completely different skullll

1 Like