It might start to die again
You cannot frame legitimate critiques of your argument as “blood in the water”.
Hippo being in cahoots with me does not make sense from any angle.
I saw your reasons, and they are wrong
I don’t see blood in the water I see someone interacting with me in an informed way
I believe that is why my head started to clear up roo
Why didn’t you mention on D1 that you knew Kazali was out of play for your math? Were you taking that into account?
–May
I did not know at the time what my ability was.
You saw my math. You can confirm that for yourself.
Hey so ash if we are good who is the demon
Do you think we are the demon or a minion
I do not know. That is what I was attempting to do earlier before you pushed me/Hippo W/W.
I simply believe that you are most likely to be the Demon.
Correct answer! When did you guess your ability?
–May
If you are going to keep being patronizing about this, then there’s not much to be done here.
I do not feel that I have been putting you down.
I feel I have established all my thoughts as clearly as possible to explain why I have reached the conclusion I have while respecting your intelligence.
BetterMittens has nominated Ash.
You know exactly what my math looks like.
You know exactly when I guessed my role.
Why ask?
Am I wrong about this?
I do not want to start a fight. I want to talk this out.
You aren’t wrong. You have been putting your thoughts down. But they are pretty much founded in wrong ways, which is why I broke apart from Kiiruma whisper early, and I wanted to see if they were because you were making them wrong or if they were legitmate. That’s actually incorrect. I didn’t have that explicit reasoning, it was mainly my intuition, anyway.
Carbonated was read by people as villager. While it’s true kills are decided by mechanics, a lot of people reading them as villager, along with being able to read through the lines, makes the kill unsurprising. Not to mention, if I was the demon I would have killed Chomp. It makes zero sense to allow a drunk village idiot to figure out they are drunk by getting provenly wrong information. That is part of why I broke away from Kiiruma because of your line of logic there.
Let’s say chomp gets a red check today. If it’s proven wrong, then it calls into question their other information, which includes me. Do you not see why I would want to kill Chomp in that scenario?
My thought process is that a Village Idiot would only get alignment. Even if he got a false redcheck, it would take a long while for us to piece that together because it would be a Minion flipping rather than a Demon.
Thus, the way I see it, you!Demon would kill Carbon instead because you know that in the hypothetical scenario where we piece together that Chomps gets a redcheck and we piece together that he’s Drunk, it would mean that Carbon’s must be accurate. It is strictly better for you to kill Carbon because Chomps being Drunk invalidates all his results while confirming all of Carbon’s (putting aside No-Dashii shenanigans).